1. Check the 2023 Stage48 Member Ranking Results, how did your Oshimen rank this year?

The 2018 Member Ranking Results (All Ranks Revealed!)

Discussion in 'Forum Events' started by kanjo, Jun 21, 2019.

  1. Lusankya

    Lusankya Next Girls Stage48 Donor

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2018
    Location:
    Germany
    Oshimen:
    Okabe Rin, Omori Maho
    Aka's name is not revealed but considering there is only one user left starting with an "A"... :^^;:
    I thought for sure he would be a casual and not such an edgelord.
     
  2. Sailor Miyawaki

    Sailor Miyawaki Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jul 31, 2018
    Oshimen:
    miyawakisakura
    15, just made it into the mainstream senbatsu :fear:
     
    • Creative Creative x 2
  3. steph

    steph Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Oct 27, 2017
    Oshimen:
    Nyan Nyan Kamen
    Im genuinely surprised I'm number 16! I thought id be higher in the mainstream ranking list :0 At least I just made it into senbatsu, one more ranking down and i would have been in undergirls [hehe]
     
  4. Aka

    Aka Under Girls

    Joined:
    Jan 4, 2013
    Oshimen:
    Sakaguchi "Tenshi" Nagisa
    Stop tagging me! You're forgetting that many at the bottom voted for unknow idols just to see their oshimen ranking higher.
     
  5. nvmea

    nvmea Under Girls

    Joined:
    Dec 31, 2014
    Location:
    Prague
    Oshimen:
    Hongo Yuzuha
    Twitter:
    nvmea
    Rumba is so unknown that she didn't even make it to the list of unknowns considered for waste voting
     
  6. Orangerafi

    Orangerafi Member

    Joined:
    Oct 22, 2018
    Location:
    Melbourne, Australia
    Oshimen:
    SeichanKomiharuMiionMacharin
    19.:blink: So I guess I missed the mainstream senbatsu then. [hehe] I was actually expecting I would be higher, like in the top 10. But undergirls is good.:banana:
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2019
  7. Crystelle

    Crystelle Next Girls

    Joined:
    Mar 27, 2015
    Location:
    Where the mountains are
    Oshimen:
    Izuta Rina, Ida Reona
    116. Crystelle
    Wow I'm even lower than I expected. I didn't even make Top 100 what a shame [hehe]
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2019
  8. bonjourmarlene

    bonjourmarlene Under Girls Wiki48 Editor

    Joined:
    Mar 21, 2016
    Location:
    UK-AUT
    Oshimen:
    小林蘭
    Twitter:
    curioushitomi
    Honestly expected to rank higher but I guess 13 is still pretty high [hehe] I still made senbatsu of casuals, I suppose lol
     
  9. May48

    May48 Future Girls

    Joined:
    Feb 17, 2017
    Oshimen:
    Ishida Chiho
    Twitter:
    May2906
    Man, Rank #66 for me. Almost got the Upcoming Girls center, what a shame being one place off [hehe]
     
  10. MrQazman

    MrQazman Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2015
    Location:
    Finland
    Oshimen:
    Takahashi Minami
    Third. :eek:
    Should change my name to MrMainstream.
     
    • Like Like x 2
  11. Jurinavenclaw

    Jurinavenclaw Future Girls

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2010
    Location:
    Laguna, Philippines
    Oshimen:
    Matsui Jurina
    Didn't even make it to the 10th sousenkyo additional category, not even close ^_^"

    I do have some members I voted for who made it to the top 50 like Jurina, Chuuri, Muto, Neru, Mako, Yuiyui, Team 8 Yui, Rena, Yuki, and even #1 girl, Okada..

    I guess my other half were mostly low ranking members :)
     
    Last edited: Jul 18, 2019
  12. Reveen

    Reveen Under Girls

    Joined:
    Feb 16, 2013
    Location:
    Sunnyvale Trailer Park
    I did a rough calculation and I presume that I'm

    18. R... (12433)

    Almost in the mainstream senbatsu then
     
  13. kanjo

    kanjo Stage48 Moderator Staff Member Stage48 Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 20, 2012
    Location:
    Ireland->Shimane
    Oshimen:
    Nishino Nanase
    I felt like, seeing everyone's reactions, that the results weren't super "accurate". So I kept trying.
    There's obviously no right answer, but I felt like the results could be something more people can accept as accurate.

    I guessed the issue was the high importance placed on what rank we gave each member.
    The difference between voting for Okada Nana for 1st and 2nd was huge. Enough to take 1st place down to 13th place.

    I still think placement should be important, but not that important.
    So, I compromised by using the square root values of the points.

    Thus
    15, 10, 9, 8, 7, 6, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1
    Became
    3.9, 3.2, 3, 2.8, 2.6, 2.4, 2.2, 2, 1.7, 1.4, 1

    I used Okada's potential ranks to test the resulting score differences, and I think it looks quite fair.
    Scoring system.png

    I'll also repost the old ranking and one with no difference for what score we gave everyone. Everyone who voted positively for Okada will get 330, and everyone who voted negatively will get -330. I'm sure you'll all hate it as much as I do.

    New ranking (points = square root of user scores * final score)
    1. T... (5658)
    2. S... (5394)
    3. bonjourmarlene (5380)
    4. Sailor Miyawaki (5286)
    5. Kiri (5206)
    6. ForrestFuller (5166)
    7. S... (5153)
    8. ColorfulMonsters48 (5136)
    9. sakutan (5057)
    10. O... (5053)
    11. Orangerafi (5044)
    12. steph (5022)
    13. Reveen (4963)
    14. E... (4947)
    15. G... (4920)
    16. S... (4864)
    17. MrQazman (4837)
    18. M... (4711)
    19. T... (4708)
    20. David B (4702)
    21. J... (4570)
    22. T... (4541)
    23. S... (4515)
    24. C... (4504)
    25. Erbeon (4463)
    26. H... (4456)
    27. K... (4390)
    28. Y... (4371)
    29. S... (4355)
    30. S... (4354)
    31. Yukitie (4340)
    32. C... (4252)
    33. Arbios (4235)
    34. I... (4224)
    35. Mana (4117)
    36. M... (4114)
    37. C... (4086)
    38. G... (4069)
    39. Generic_User (4015)
    40. R... (4002)
    41. S... (3938)
    42. H... (3861)
    43. Rurouni (3835)
    44. B... (3803)
    45. Mikuriin (3801)
    46. Zerase (3786)
    47. Heelo (3776)
    48. F... (3764)
    49. Q... (3759)
    50. SaitoWinterStar (3697)
    51. V... (3688)
    52. Y... (3640)
    53. dutchie (3631)
    54. S... (3628)
    55. sakusakukamen (3546)
    56. ysa73 (3511)
    57. N... (3507)
    58. MaiAkikoChan (3488)
    59. Y... (3467)
    60. K... (3466)
    61. J... (3457)
    62. Z... (3393)
    63. J... (3388)
    64. R... (3337)
    65. T... (3308)
    65. H... (3308)
    67. Tommy Idoc (3306)
    68. F... (3301)
    69. Crossheart (3296)
    70. D... (3267)
    71. theobserver (3239)
    72. M... (3225)
    73. T... (3213)
    74. convenience93 (3153)
    75. G... (3149)
    76. E... (3115)
    77. G... (3109)
    78. G... (3103)
    79. wlerin (3082)
    80. half23 (3081)
    81. H... (3073)
    82. NyanNyan's Pet (3069)
    83. halcyon (3063)
    84. May48 (3017)
    85. Kanjo (3015)
    86. G... (3005)
    87. N... (2969)
    87. Tuhis (2969)
    89. sscrla (2921)
    90. Seditious85 (2906)
    91. Lusankya (2899)
    92. M... (2865)
    93. W... (2853)
    94. JoltFiend (2851)
    95. D... (2823)
    96. T... (2821)
    97. N... (2809)
    98. P... (2805)
    99. T... (2735)
    100. S... (2683)
    101. L... (2662)
    102. M... (2644)
    103. D... (2625)
    104. E... (2575)
    105. R... (2570)
    106. T... (2552)
    107. Jurinavenclaw (2445)
    108. K... (2421)
    109. ethereallimbo (2353)
    110. S... (2209)
    111. nvmea (2196)
    111. H... (2196)
    113. J... (2159)
    114. Crystelle (2154)
    115. nigamushiotoko (2124)
    116. Q... (2085)
    117. S... (2036)
    118. M... (2018)
    119. T... (1997)
    120. R... (1982)
    121. P... (1940)
    122. C... (1911)
    123. A... (1824)
    124. H... (1802)
    125. hjr1891 (1778)
    126. Tk-Tonkla (1768)
    127. F... (1728)
    128. G... (1727)
    129. F... (1677)
    130. M... (1649)
    131. F... (1607)
    132. I... (1604)
    133. R... (1591)
    134. G... (1545)
    135. L... (1474)
    136. M... (1451)
    137. U... (1360)
    138. Cristafari (1305)
    139. S... (1209)
    140. N... (1203)
    141. L... (1181)
    142. T... (1179)
    143. M... (1132)
    144. T... (1113)
    145. U... (1099)
    146. C... (903)
    147. S... (801)
    148. EinhanderX (380)

    Bonus ranking 1, the old system (points = sum of user scores * final scores)
    1. Kiri (14395)
    2. O... (14202)
    3. MrQazman (13682)
    4. T... (13470)
    5. S... (13415)
    6. E... (13281)
    7. ForrestFuller (13176)
    8. sakutan (13073)
    9. S... (13071)
    10. ColorfulMonsters48 (13028)
    11. S... (12796)
    12. T... (12794)
    13. bonjourmarlene (12775)
    14. J... (12621)
    15. Sailor Miyawaki (12590)
    16. steph (12482)
    17. C... (12459)
    18. Reveen (12433)
    19. Orangerafi (11948)
    20. G... (11905)
    21. K... (11878)
    22. G... (11703)
    23. Erbeon (11425)
    24. T... (11422)
    25. David B (11376)
    26. S... (11149)
    27. M... (11070)
    28. Y... (10999)
    29. F... (10971)
    30. S... (10892)
    31. H... (10794)
    32. R... (10765)
    33. I... (10763)
    34. Rurouni (10759)
    35. C... (10686)
    36. Yukitie (10360)
    37. C... (10336)
    38. S... (10321)
    39. B... (10276)
    40. Generic_User (10269)
    41. H... (10113)
    42. Arbios (10026)
    43. Mana (9979)
    44. M... (9939)
    45. V... (9821)
    46. T... (9816)
    47. S... (9815)
    48. Y... (9796)
    49. Mikuriin (9783)
    50. N... (9630)
    51. Zerase (9582)
    52. Q... (9567)
    53. Y... (9376)
    54. sakusakukamen (9332)
    55. SaitoWinterStar (9284)
    56. R... (8982)
    57. Heelo (8950)
    58. K... (8793)
    59. T... (8737)
    60. N... (8728)
    61. Kanjo (8717)
    62. J... (8591)
    63. Z... (8442)
    64. W... (8273)
    65. Tommy Idoc (8260)
    66. May48 (8224)
    67. ysa73 (8192)
    68. theobserver (8135)
    69. G... (8115)
    70. NyanNyan's Pet (8043)
    71. H... (8017)
    72. MaiAkikoChan (7971)
    73. S... (7941)
    74. F... (7921)
    75. J... (7836)
    76. dutchie (7822)
    77. S... (7810)
    78. E... (7626)
    79. H... (7605)
    80. sscrla (7586)
    81. D... (7517)
    82. L... (7428)
    83. wlerin (7411)
    84. G... (7328)
    85. halcyon (7321)
    86. half23 (7319)
    87. M... (7316)
    88. Crossheart (7308)
    89. Lusankya (7189)
    90. Seditious85 (7180)
    91. convenience93 (7142)
    92. T... (7044)
    93. D... (6926)
    94. M... (6907)
    95. D... (6773)
    96. T... (6737)
    97. P... (6663)
    98. Tuhis (6661)
    99. JoltFiend (6643)
    100. T... (6623)
    101. J... (6579)
    102. G... (6554)
    103. G... (6533)
    104. M... (6412)
    105. R... (6388)
    106. ethereallimbo (6382)
    107. E... (6360)
    108. K... (6002)
    109. S... (5925)
    110. T... (5875)
    111. M... (5829)
    112. nigamushiotoko (5818)
    113. N... (5749)
    114. C... (5725)
    115. Jurinavenclaw (5681)
    116. Crystelle (5537)
    117. P... (5433)
    118. R... (5324)
    119. nvmea (5149)
    120. F... (5080)
    121. S... (4931)
    122. H... (4864)
    123. Q... (4782)
    124. H... (4758)
    125. hjr1891 (4650)
    126. A... (4626)
    127. T... (4367)
    128. Tk-Tonkla (4305)
    129. M... (4187)
    130. F... (4107)
    131. I... (3949)
    132. G... (3850)
    133. R... (3798)
    134. F... (3696)
    135. U... (3647)
    136. G... (3622)
    137. L... (3307)
    138. M... (3285)
    139. U... (3162)
    140. N... (3051)
    141. L... (2986)
    142. Cristafari (2983)
    143. S... (2813)
    144. M... (2605)
    145. T... (2383)
    146. S... (2206)
    147. C... (2025)
    148. EinhanderX (1017)

    Bonus ranking 2, (points = sum of final scores)
    1. T... (2717)
    2. Sailor Miyawaki (2538)
    3. bonjourmarlene (2529)
    4. S... (2461)
    5. ColorfulMonsters48 (2422)
    6. Orangerafi (2376)
    7. S... (2367)
    8. steph (2351)
    9. G... (2346)
    10. M... (2273)
    11. ForrestFuller (2248)
    12. David B (2220)
    13. sakutan (2192)
    14. S... (2184)
    15. Reveen (2139)
    16. Kiri (2138)
    17. S... (2078)
    18. Arbios (2076)
    19. E... (2074)
    20. Yukitie (2072)
    21. H... (2058)
    22. O... (2029)
    23. Erbeon (2020)
    24. T... (2005)
    25. Y... (1966)
    26. C... (1963)
    27. T... (1952)
    28. S... (1951)
    29. dutchie (1949)
    30. I... (1943)
    31. Heelo (1936)
    32. M... (1934)
    33. S... (1929)
    34. S... (1910)
    35. Mana (1898)
    36. MrQazman (1886)
    37. ysa73 (1847)
    38. J... (1844)
    39. C... (1824)
    40. K... (1822)
    41. C... (1813)
    42. Zerase (1811)
    43. S... (1796)
    44. Generic_User (1759)
    45. H... (1696)
    46. Q... (1695)
    47. Crossheart (1693)
    48. Mikuriin (1679)
    49. J... (1677)
    50. R... (1673)
    51. MaiAkikoChan (1670)
    52. SaitoWinterStar (1668)
    53. convenience93 (1656)
    54. N... (1651)
    55. M... (1638)
    56. G... (1615)
    57. B... (1604)
    58. Rurouni (1596)
    58. J... (1596)
    60. H... (1587)
    61. G... (1582)
    62. D... (1575)
    63. F... (1555)
    64. Z... (1552)
    64. G... (1552)
    66. sakusakukamen (1541)
    67. Tuhis (1533)
    68. wlerin (1528)
    69. theobserver (1522)
    70. G... (1519)
    71. K... (1516)
    72. V... (1481)
    72. E... (1481)
    74. Y... (1480)
    75. Tommy Idoc (1456)
    76. N... (1445)
    77. F... (1444)
    78. half23 (1434)
    79. Y... (1432)
    80. JoltFiend (1415)
    81. NyanNyan's Pet (1394)
    82. halcyon (1390)
    83. R... (1389)
    84. G... (1384)
    85. T... (1354)
    86. T... (1335)
    86. M... (1335)
    88. Seditious85 (1315)
    89. Lusankya (1313)
    90. P... (1311)
    91. D... (1310)
    92. H... (1289)
    93. T... (1281)
    94. sscrla (1278)
    95. M... (1264)
    96. May48 (1200)
    97. N... (1199)
    98. D... (1184)
    99. T... (1178)
    100. E... (1175)
    101. Kanjo (1167)
    102. R... (1150)
    103. W... (1146)
    104. H... (1137)
    105. T... (1136)
    106. L... (1116)
    107. Jurinavenclaw (1111)
    108. K... (1090)
    109. nvmea (1062)
    110. ethereallimbo (1008)
    111. Q... (1006)
    112. S... (1000)
    113. S... (991)
    114. Crystelle (946)
    115. S... (892)
    116. G... (871)
    117. nigamushiotoko (861)
    118. R... (855)
    119. H... (823)
    120. Tk-Tonkla (818)
    121. P... (813)
    122. F... (800)
    123. M... (793)
    124. A... (784)
    124. F... (784)
    126. C... (780)
    127. R... (764)
    128. G... (757)
    129. J... (756)
    130. T... (755)
    131. M... (752)
    132. M... (750)
    133. hjr1891 (745)
    134. L... (730)
    135. F... (721)
    136. T... (712)
    137. I... (708)
    138. Cristafari (653)
    139. S... (599)
    140. M... (576)
    141. U... (563)
    142. L... (541)
    143. N... (521)
    144. C... (451)
    145. U... (433)
    146. S... (311)
    147. T... (235)
    148. EinhanderX (174)
     
  14. Jurinavenclaw

    Jurinavenclaw Future Girls

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2010
    Location:
    Laguna, Philippines
    Oshimen:
    Matsui Jurina
    Wait, seriously, there were "complaints" or "questions" against putting weight on the ranking given?

    I think that made sense.

    Like obviously there's a big difference between someone who put Okada as their #1 girl from someone who placed her at 20th on their list.

    You can't say they are "equally mainstream" on that part.
     
  15. sscrla

    sscrla Stage48 Moderator Staff Member Stage48 Moderator

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2015
    Oshimen:
    Takayanagi Akane
    Now we just need to average our three rankings: (89 + 80 + 94)/3 = 88 :)
     
  16. kanjo

    kanjo Stage48 Moderator Staff Member Stage48 Moderator

    Joined:
    Aug 20, 2012
    Location:
    Ireland->Shimane
    Oshimen:
    Nishino Nanase
    No, just a lot of surprise.
    I didn't get rid of it, I just reduced it.
    It's still a big factor, just not as big.

    And I still kept the old one so people can judge themselves based on whichever rank they agree with the most.

    @sscrla that's already close to what the new ranking does ;)
     
    • Like Like x 1
  17. Reveen

    Reveen Under Girls

    Joined:
    Feb 16, 2013
    Location:
    Sunnyvale Trailer Park
    So I got 13, 18 and 15 respectively in the three computations, which makes me the Takahashi Juri or Takayanagi Akane of voters or something lol
     
  18. Sailor Miyawaki

    Sailor Miyawaki Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jul 31, 2018
    Oshimen:
    miyawakisakura
    Made it to mainstream kami 7 now [hehe]
     
  19. Jurinavenclaw

    Jurinavenclaw Future Girls

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2010
    Location:
    Laguna, Philippines
    Oshimen:
    Matsui Jurina
    107, 115, 107.. so regardless, way low to be mainstream.

    Apparently though, its my negative votes that really brought my score down.

    Here are my negative votes:

    - 5: Sakura
    There were members, through out the last 10 elections, who were deeply devastated with their results: Takajo, Yuria, comes to mind. However, at least those members still sucked it up and showed up for the group photos.

    -4: Hirate
    Honestly, since I submitted my list at the last minute, I didn't edit or think enough from my 2017 list. Still not a fan of her and will check out Keyaki again once they give to another member the centership. Hirate will likely be out of my negative list next year.

    -3: Minegishi
    Her act years ago was the worst act any member had done that put AKB in such a badlight in the international scene. After that, sure, she was given the chance to redeem herself (coz AKS was put on the spot and won't dare fire the girl who shaved het head), that's the thing, should have left gracefully after Team 4 with the musketeers won request hour.

    Didn't happen, the leeching continues.

    -2: Sashi
    More of a habit. I know there's an argument that she's probably the greatest member of AKB, still, not really a fan. I stopped disliking her years ago but I just can't be bothered to remove her from my negative list.

    -1: Matsuoka
    The overpushed poster girl. Good for her that almost all popular members of HKT left already that it can now be argued that she deserves the push she's being given. I'll probably remove her from my list next year.

    There you have it. The reasons why I ranked low, I downvoted several Stage48 favorites. Apparently, if I didn't, I would have ranked somewhere between 60 to 80. So somewhat in the median.
     
    • Dislike Dislike x 4
    • Like Like x 1
  20. MrQazman

    MrQazman Kenkyuusei

    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2015
    Location:
    Finland
    Oshimen:
    Takahashi Minami
    17 / 3 / 36.
    Interesting. I won't be changing my name after all. :hehe:
     

Share This Page