The 2015 Stage48 Member Ranking Results

01.
02. 30. (36) [32|0] Shiroma Miru{+166,0}, 166
03.
04. 64. (51) [18|0] Shibata Aya{+83,0}, 83
05.
06. 29. (23) [42|0] Takahashi Juri{+170,0}, 170
07. 102. (111) [22|16] Suda Akari{+99,-48}, 51
08. 177. (140) [10|1] Aigasa Moe{+29,-5}, 24
09. 12. (11) [56|8] Kojima Haruna{+284,-19}, 265
10. 38. (47) [32|0] Nakanishi Chiyori{+132,0}, 132
11. 25. (26) [33|0] Takayanagi Akane{+183,0}, 183
12.
13.
14. 105. (70) [9|0] Oba Mina{+49,0}, 49
15.
16.
17. 36. (47) [29|5] Kato Rena{+155,-12}, 143
18. 28. (15) [46|23] Sashihara Rino{+246,-74}, 172
19. 17. (39) [48|5] Komiyama Haruka{+242,-13}, 229
20. 185. (---) [6|1] Jessica Veranda{+24,-2}, 22

Happy to see so many I voted for are in the top 10 (was expecting so but still). Also hitting myself in the head because I forgot to add graduates, sorry Rena </3

 

Well now that Tanochan has ranked, this is going to be my last time posting in this thread, so I'll just post the remainder of my ranking as well.

01. (+15) 36. (47) [29|5] Kato Rena{+155,-12}, 143
02. (+10) 16. (17) [47|2] Tano Yuka{+244,-7}, 237
03. (+9) 49. (69) [26|2] Hirata Rina{+113,-6}, 107
04. (+8) 102. (119) [10|0] Ichikawa Manami{+51,0}, 51
05. (+7) 29. (23) [42|0] Takahashi Juri{+170,0}, 170
06. (+6) Shimazaki Haruka
07. (+5) 30. (36) [32|0] Shiroma Miru{+166,0}, 166
08. (+5) 17. (39) [48|5] Komiyama Haruka{+242,-13}, 229
09. (+4) 57. (21) [33|6] Owada Nana{+111,-18}, 93
10. (+4) 81. (107) [15|0] Omori Miyu{+66,0}, 66
11. (+4) 44. (---) [30|1] Goto Rara{+118,-2}, 116
12. (+3) 39. (32) [34|6] Kizaki Yuria{+152,-22}, 130
13. (+3) Watanabe Miyuki
14. (+3) 105. (58) [15|2] Oshima Ryoka{+55,-6}, 49
15. (+2) 11. (27) [63|5] Mukaichi Mion{+293,-17}, 276
16. (+2) 174. (158) [10|1] Yamashita Emiri{+28,-3}, 25
17. (+2) Miyawaki Sakura
18. (+1) Yamamoto Sayaka
19. (+1) 90. (74) [16|1] Azuma Rion{+62,-3}, 59
20. (+1) 110. (---) [12|0] Yamaguchi Maho{+48,0}, 48

 

GO MOMOKA (y)

 

Updates.

Spoiler

01. ...
02. Matsui Rena (+10) (14)
03. Kotani Riho (+9) (128)
04. ...
05. Iwata Karen (+7) (46)
06. ...
07. Moriyasu Madoka (+5) (79)
08. Fujie Reina (+5) (100)
09. Takayanagi Akane (+4) (25)
10. Muto Tomu (+4) (35)
11. Tano Yuka (+4) (16)
12. Oba Mina (+3) (105)
13. Miyazawa Sae (+3) (14)
14. Miyazaki Miho (+3) (72)
15. Umeda Ayaka (+2) (66)
16. Kato Minami (+2) (32)
17. Ogasawara Mayu (+2) (83)
18. ...
19. Goto Rara (+1) (44)
20. Oya Masana (+1) (75)

Was surprise that Rena and Sae are both same position.
4 member left. 1 AKB 2 NMB 1 HKT

 

Sasshi fans need to stop making childish comments like this. I stumbled on this a lot.

Oh look, someone dislike Sasshi, so he/she must be a butthurt hater who got jealous of her #1 SSK. Because Sasshi is such a perfect human that there's no way you can find anything objectionable about her, right?

I didn't participate on this voting, so those downvotes were not from me. But I'm one of people who actually (kinda) dislike Sasshi. (Or to be precise, she was actually one of my favs in the past, until it hit a U-turn).

I'm a Yukirin oshi (she never wins SSK), yet I don't have any issues with Acchan/Yuko/Mayuyu (other SSK winners), only with Sasshi; so there goes your theory down the drain.

Especially in the context of the voting in this thread, it's within the rules of the game to downvote some members.

 

because of one fans say something towards the result doesn't mean all of her fans is like that. This applied to all of the member fans. You really don't have to get so offensive about that, everyone have a right to state their opinion about their oshi, is not like he/she attack your oshi like you did right now right?



Anywaaay getting off topic again,
I really thrilled to saw tomonaga mio get so much + point, she surely would raise up in senbatsu this year.
And katomina!! Wow her perky yet a lil bit dorkyness really win people's heart. I wish NGT had more show so I can see her more. And does anyone care to lighten me up about takamina's point??

 

Lol, of course I never meant every single (100.00%) of Sasshi fans ever said something like that.

And btw, the comments from sasshinaction that I quoted, he/she was not stating his/her opinion about his/her oshi ; he/she's judging people who downvote/dislike Sasshi to be simply haters who are jealous of her success, which I refuted.

 

yeah about that I really agree with you, everyone have their right to give any point good or bad. We can't generalized all of them must be jealous of her. Thanks for the explanation I really appreciate it

 

I'm glad to see Miichan got better results than last year. Apart from several hardcore haters I guess the rest who used to downvote her have forgiven her scandal, don't care anymore or have left the forum...

 

i have failed you... my last-minute plan to give Ricchan my maximum points failed and it's inturn robbed you of you top #100 positions...

 

Dislike a member =/= Downvote a member

Really. Someone downvoting a member does not necessarily mean that he/she is disliking the downvoted member, let alone hating her.

Spoiler: Downvote

I downvoted for Thalia, Nina, Sakura, Dasu and Sasshi (in that order, yes).
I downvoted Thalia for her way of handling her issues, including before she (was allowed to) quit and after. Specifically, her response & explanations regarding her scandal & fans reacting to it. Like, what?! Fans are supposed to know such bts scene??! Be professional, as long as your front is a member of idol group, you have to maintain the image that you are supposed to maintain, nothing more nothing less, or get the whole ordeal over with quickly and neatly.
Nina because of her scandal and her poor way of handling it. But what's more, the disappointment that comes with such poor way of handling the whole ordeal.
Sakura... well, I'd say the pushes, right on my face, but really, mgmt chose her and she does a really good job to deliver her chunk of cuteness and goodness. I'd also say that I didn't really like her demonstration of failing in sport. Even if she was bad, it wouldn't be that bad unless she was aiming to get all eyes on her. It's a tryhard? But I can definitely say that I don't specifically hate her person. What sets me off the most is her SSK speech. Call me ignorant for taking her words at its face-vakue and not trying to understand what she meant between the lines of her speech, but no matter what, I still don't like her statement of desiring to crush AKB48 when she's, a fan of 48G can say, not an AKB full-blood. It's more like, my thought was like, "How dare she!" So, I'd be super glad if she was completely made as an AKB member.
Then comes Dasu. She was on a tight race with Haruppi for the undergirls center, but lost. Nothing grand with my reasoning, but she sets me off when she delivered such a speech in such a manner.
Lastly, Sasshi. I have always been on a like-indifference-makemeuncomfortable basis with Sasshi. Sometimes I would see her and think, Wow she's not bad. But other times, or soon after, from another girl, I question, "Is this how an idol is supposed to look like?" Sasshi especially set me off the wrong way when she has been placed as if she's the center. I'm still salty about 12Byou positions, what WSakuruppi center is this! The media focused on Sasshi more.

 

This and that are two different things. Accepting that there are people who don't like your oshi and getting along them and fans of different members getting along are different aspects. What narrow-minded is trying to dissuade people about how they feel about a person because feeling upset is petty.

 

Good thing this is a fan forum and nothing you say will ever reach the members themselves so even if you hate them you're basically just venting your frustrations pointlessly to an audience who doesn't care in the slightest unless they're bored enough to reply to you or god forbid emotionally overreactive enough to actually take offense to a random person's dislike for an idol and two weeks from now no one will even remember this happened except the mod you gave a pointless headache to who has to clean it up

Nihilism wins errytime, yeahhh!

 

That's only partly true, and the truth is easy to uncover. If you downvote a member it may mean you aren't happy with the things that member said o did in the last year, and that's ok....but if you downvote that member every year, don't try to fool everyone saying you don't dislike her, because you actually dislike or even hate that member.

 

My vote results

01.
02. Mukaichi Mion (+10) 11
03. Kojima Mako (+9) 20
04. Owada Nana (+8) 57
05. Nakanishi Chiyori (+7) 38
06.
07.
08. Kojima Haruna (+5) 12
09.
10. Sashihara Rino (+4) 28
11. Tomonaga Mio (+4) 60
12. Tano Yuka (+3) 16
13. Rena Kato (+3) 36
14. Iwatate Saho (+3) 62
15. Muto Tomu (+2) 35
16. Maeda Ami (+2) 62
17. Kizaki Yuria (+2) 39
18.
19. Abe Maria (+1) 185
20. Tashima Meru (+1) 24

 

ithebigc however said that you should only downvote a member if you dislike them for personal reasons. So, uh, ok.

 

I am sooo surprised! My beloved Mikichan ranked so high, yeah! And I was sure she would get a lot of negs, since many people find her annoying, but she really did fine this year!
But what surprise me even more is... why my beloved Sasshi is so low? This is the kind of surprises I don't like... Anyway, Stage48 fandom is reeaaally different from japanese one.

 

While it's true that the Japanese and outside of Japan fandoms are completely different... Sasshi would probably be in the same place, except with more positive votes and more negative votes. Although she's super popular, popular enough to rank 1st wit 194,000 votes, her anti's are almost as numerous as her fans, for wota at least; the general public is a different story. But either way, Sasshi has diehard fans and diehard haters, so negatives were bound to happen.

 

01. Oba Mina (+15)
02. Jonishi Kei (+10)
03. Murashige Anna (+9) - My HKT Oshi, and my surprise ranking I'm glad she managed to get into the top 25 against all the other girls! Here's to hoping this will translate into the real SSK
04. Imaizumi Yui (+8)
05. Nakamura Ayuka (+7)
06. ???? (+6)
07. Shiraishi Mai (+5)
08. ???? (+5)
09. Anai Chihiro (+4)
10. Oya Masana (+4)
11. Furuhata Nao (+4)
12. Ikuta Erika (+3) - I always thought she grew up to epitomise the perfect girl for Nogi: lady-like beauty with an angelic singing voice. Coupled with amazing piano skills and a gift for comedic timing, she's a threat that is still on the rise
13. Kitano Hinako (+3)
14. Yokoyama Yui (Team 8) (+3)
15. ???? (+2)
16. Furukawa Airi (+2)
17. Mizusawa Ayaka (+2)
18. Shibata Aya (+1)
19. Sakurai Reika (+1)
20. Iwata Karen (+1)

And so I'm down to my last 3, whom I completely expected to be near the top About the people who gave negative votes to Aanya and Ikuchan: I don't know who you are, and I don't know why you downvoted them. But what I do have is a very particular set of skills. I will look for you, I will find you,... and I will give you a very detailed 30 minute lecture as to why you are wrong

 

1. Miyazawa Sae (+15) [14]
2. Kinoshita Momoka (+10) [55]
3. Kitagawa Ryoha (+9) [47]
6. Matsui Jurina (+6) [13]
7. Goto Rara (+5) [44]
10. Iwasa Misaki (+4) [72]
11. Matsumoto Chikako (+4) [199]
12. Sashihara Rino (+3) [28]
13. Tani Marika (+3) [33]
14. Matsui Rena (+3) [14]
15. Hamamatsu Riona (+2) [246]
16. Otaki Yuria (+2) [299]
17. Jo Eriko (+2) [127]
18. Tano Yuka (+1) [16]
19. Sato Shiori (Team 8) (+1) [376]
20. Mogi Kasumi (+1) [394]

1. Maeda Ami (-5)