Best and worst singers in 48G

I don't see Yukirin as a good singer. She is just so average.

The best one is still Sayanee for me. The another one is Miyu.

 

If Yukirin is average, does that make other members below below below below average?

 

Even they're not official members yet, I think Shekinah Arzaga of MNL has the best(?) voice in the ALL48 Group...
Try listening to her once on YT, she was a contender on a national singing competition

 

I have never rank 48G high on vocal abilities anyway In 48G, she's a fairly good singer, but comparing to actual singers then...

 

if the video does not show watch the video here

 

^

must be so fun going karaoke with her lol

 

JKT48 Medley Acoustic (Shonichi+365+Aitakkata) in Bangkok 2018


if the video does not show watch the video here

and also, JKT48 wins in terms of language

if the video does not show watch the video here
in here they talk 4 languages : english, japan, indonesia, and thai

 

Best singer : Masuda Yuka, Yamamoto Sayaka, Iwasa Misaki, Iwata Karen, Kashiwagi Yuki, Akimoto Sayaka, Kuramochi Asuka, Ogasawara Mayu

 

Top-notch first best singers but not my favourite (just different taste): Misaki Iwasa, Masuda Yuka
Second best singers and my favourite: Takeuchi Miyu, Kashiwagi Yuki, Kawamura Mahiro (Nogizaka46)
Other honorable mentions : Yamamoto Sayaka, Katayama Haruka, Kuramochi Asuka, Umeda Ayaka

Some live performances:

Masuda Yuka:

if the video does not show watch the video here

Takeuchi Miyu:

if the video does not show watch the video here

Kashiwagi Yuki:

if the video does not show watch the video here

if the video does not show watch the video here

Kawamura Mahiro:

if the video does not show watch the video here

While it's true that AKB48 and its sister groups aren't meant to deliver a high quality singing performance (almost all of their best singers had never made it into senbatsu), it is the process of finding who is the best singer in the group that is very interesting to us. If I want to listen to the high quality singers, I can just pick those professional singers and bands out there, check who receives awards, etc. But to find who is the best singers (as well as who is our favourite singers) inside this idol group, it is what makes it fun and interesting.

For example, when I decided to pick Kashiwagi Yuki as my kami-oshi, I didn't know she was actually a pretty good singer (above average in the groups). Initially I was only attracted by her beauty, personality, group performances, etc. And so I was pleasantly surprised when I learned about her singing ability, and over time I had grown to like her voice more and more. I believe everyone here also felt like this toward their oshis eventhough they know their oshis are not the best singers in the group. It is this kind of process that makes wota-ing over idols is so fun and intriguing. And it's always fun to see these girls fan-girling over their own comrade who is absolutely better than them at that department.

My question now is, amongst the current members (the new-gen members), who has the best voice and singing ability?

 

STU48 draft 3 Yura Akari

if the video does not show watch the video here

STU48 Imamura Mitsuki

if the video does not show watch the video here

STU48 Ishida Chiho

if the video does not show watch the video here

well, basically ex-ASH (actor school hiroshima) girls can do really well both as a performer and singer

 

Okubo Miori (BNK48) - maybe not the best singer, but this is my favourite version of Nandemonaiya (Your Name).


if the video does not show watch the video here

 

Chiyuu’s performance of Yokosuka Story showed amazing improvement after her idol days. Shame I did not rip it from youtube.

 

Obviously...


if the video does not show watch the video here

She's so good she won't even bother with the singing competion.

 

is this sarcasm?

 

Calm down, this is not Sakura.