Discussion in 'General BNK48 Discussion' started by ForrestFuller, Mar 27, 2017.
What happened to Mind?
Direct quote of what people have told me on Discord (can't confirm it cause I don't speak Thai)
"The short version is that she said some not so nice things about not wanting to shake hands with a certain type of fans(people who said or acted innapropriate). What she said blew up and was made to look like she didn’t want to do handshake events and didn’t like the people who go to those events in general. I don’t remember if this was confirmed but she had also appearantly been caught drinking (Mind is underage) and rumours that don’t seem to be true that she had a boyfriend. After this happened it came out that people have been harrassing her online for a while now. Also it looks like antis have started planning sending explicit pictures to members DMs. It’s a bit of a mess right now."
"Right now it’s difficult to say exactly what happened. But from the statement IAM made and Mind’s statement it looks like the punishment is related to the secret account and the drinking. From what I can tell most BNK fans are upset with IAM again for not protecting the members from the harassment at Handshake events and online."
"Mind is demoted to KKS
For having a secret insta account and taking selfie with another person"
"Oh also included: Underaged drinking and berating perverted fans"
TLDR; looks like she told people off for being creepy at HS events, had a private instagram account that was found and drank alcohol while underage.
10/4/2020 BNK48 upload new song 「心でふれて」 (Kokoro de furerte) / Touch by heart Japanese Ver.
Apr 17, 2020 CGM48 upload new version of Touch by heart in Lanna Version (The North Local Language in Thailand)
Apr 21, 2020 BNK48 upload new version of Touch by heart in English Version
I feel like this one sounds the most different. I really like the instruments chosen for this version.
For anyone, who's lost track (in order of when they were released):
Thai version (2nd April)
Cherprang, Jennis, Pun, Tarwaan, Pupe, Izurina, Aom
=> BNK and CGM captains + vice captains
Japanese version (14th April)
Izurina, Miori, Satchan, Kaimook, Music, Jaa
=> Japanese members + members who speak Japanese
Lanna version (17th April)
Izurina, Aom, Milk, Parima, Pepo, Champoo, Marmink, Kaiwan, Angel, Nena, Nicha, Fahsai, Neni, Latin, Ping, Meen, Pim, Fortune, mei, Jayda, Jjae, Kaning, Punch
=> all CGM48 members
Special version (19th April)
=> all members (BNK48 + trainees, CGM48 + trainees)
English version (21st April)
Noey, Kaew, Tarwaan, Maneung, Orn
I believe there's more people in BNK that can speak English pretty well (I remember Cherprang, Jennis and Pun once did a 45min interview in English) but I assume they chose a handful of members. Especially since Cherprang, Jennis and Pun are already part of the Captain/original version
Three Vlogs of Cherprang in Laos have been posted. While they focus on her, you can catch glimpses of other members. For example, here is my favorite.
Japanese Version, Japanese members + Unit Mimigumo
Special Version, The version is open in BNK48 9th Single General Election Live Announcement.
Apr 28, 2020 BNK48 upload new version of Touch by heart in Chinese Version.
BNK48 Team BIII: Jane, Kate, Wee
BNK48 Team NV: Gggee, Mewnich, Phukkhom
BNK48 Trainee: Pakwan
BNK48 world domination