Overall Idol Ranking Thread

Discussion in 'The STAGE48 Idol Emporium' started by maxaroni, Oct 7, 2010.

  1. maxaroni

    maxaroni Kenkyuusei

    Jan 25, 2009
    As you can see from the fact that S48 has an Idol Emporium, most of us have been or are currently fans of other idol groups/conglomerates such as Hello! Project or Johnny's Entertainment. Since we are, we obviously have opinions about these other idols, so I thought "why not start a ranking thread for ALL THE IDOLS."

    I'm not expecting you to rank every idol you know cause that'd be just ridiculous. Include as many as you want though xD and to clear up any confusion, maybe put their group or w/e in parentheses after their name :D

    TOP 10 IDOLS
    1: Takajo Aki (AKB48)
    2: Hirajima Natsumi (AKB48)
    3: Sato Natsuki (AKB48)
    4: Ariyasu Momoka (Momoiro Clover)
    5: Hiramatsu Kanako (SKE48)
    6: Nito Moeno (AKB48)
    7: JunJun (Morning Musume)
    8: Fukuda Kanon (S/mileage)
    9: Michishige Sayumi (Morning Musume)
    10: Aikawa Kozue (DANCEROiD)
  2. Naomi

    Naomi Kenkyuusei Retired Staff

    Oct 11, 2007
    There's already a Hello! Project ranking thread here, but I was thinking that maybe the two threads should be merged (or close the H!P one) since there's not a Hello! Project section anymore...

    Anyway, I love to rank stuff, therefore I love this thread. :B

    Top 9 Idols
    01. Yoshizawa Hitomi (Ex-Morning Musume)
    02. Matsubara Natsumi (AKB48)
    03. Akimoto Sayaka (AKB48)
    04. Ishikawa Rika (Ex-Morning Musume)
    05. Okai Chisato (C-ute)
    06. Matsui Sakiko (AKB48)
    07. Sashihara Rino (AKB48)
    08. Niigaki Risa (Morning Musume)
    09. Furukawa Airi (SKE48)

    Yes, Top 9 because it'd be a tie between Hyoyeon (SNSD), Hara (KARA), and Tsuji Nozomi (ex-Morning Musume), and I have no idea who to choose.

    Most if it is AKB48 and H!P because they're really the only idols I've followed closely enough to rank them. With other groups, I don't follow the members individually as much.
  3. aznnerd

    aznnerd Kenkyuusei

    Oct 16, 2009
    Texas, USA
    O: Fun!
    I see everyone as of now (aka the two above me lmao) have been choosing female idols. It needs some guy love up in this hizz house :D

    Top 10 Idols
    1. Tiffany (SNSD)
    2. Watanabe Mayu (AKB48)
    3. JoKwon (2AM)
    4. Hirajima Natsumi (AKB48)
    5. Ota Aika (AKB48)
    6. TaeYang (Big Bang)
    7. Younha (She counts as an idol right? [think])
    8. Nicole/Seungyeon (KARA)
    9. The rest of SNSD
    10. Eunjung (T-ARA) + Sungmin/Kyuhyun (Super Junior)

    I got so many ties, but I can't decide lol
  4. Naomi

    Naomi Kenkyuusei Retired Staff

    Oct 11, 2007
    There aren't too many male idols that I like. The only ones I can think of are Kame from KAT-TUN and Taemin from SHINee (or any of the other members), but I have no idea where I'd put them. My favorite male celebrity is Shou from Alice Nine, though, but he's not an idol, otherwise he'd be in my Top 10 somewhere. xD
  5. Kana

    Kana Kenkyuusei

    Jul 24, 2007
    Alone in an ocean full of tears...
    Top 8 idols
    #1 Tiffany (SNSD) & Michishige Sayumi (Morning Musume)
    #3 Itano Tomomi (AKB48)
    #4 Oshima Yuko (AKB48)
    #5 Sato Natsuki (AKB48)
    #6 Jessica (SNSD)
    #7 Sugaya Risako (Berryz Kobo)
    #8 Arihara Kanna (ex-°C-ute)

    <3 :love:
  6. Cristafari

    Cristafari Stage48 Admin Staff Member Stage48 Admin

    Sep 10, 2008
    Saitama, Japan
    Iwasa Misaki

    1. Ohori Megumi (SDN48)
    2. Iwasa Misaki (AKB48)
    3. Yazawa Erika (Idoling!!!)
    4. Tanaka Reina (MoMusu)
    5. Hatakeyama Chisaki (SDN48)
    6. Komori Mika (AKB48)
    7. Ariyasu Momoka (Momoiro Clover)
    8. Ohe Tomomi (ex-AKB)
    9. Sudo Maasa (Berryz Kobo)
    10. Ogura Yui (YuiKaori)

    BTW, like Max I adore Kozue. But I am not ready to crown her as a full blown idol yet. :inlove:
  7. Kana

    Kana Kenkyuusei

    Jul 24, 2007
    Alone in an ocean full of tears...
    OMG Shame on me. I forgot Meetan in my list :cry:
    Corrected list:
    #1 Tiffany (SNSD) & Michishige Sayumi (Morning Musume)
    #3 Ohori Megumi (SDN48) & Itano Tomomi (AKB48)
    #5 Oshima Yuko (AKB48)
    #6 Sato Natsuki (AKB48)
    #7 Jessica (SNSD)
    #8 Sugaya Risako (Berryz Kobo)
    #9 Arihara Kanna (ex-°C-ute)
  8. erikachi

    erikachi Kenkyuusei

    Oct 3, 2010
    1. Itano Tomomi
    2. Kasai Tomomi
    3. aiko
    4. Tiffany
  9. KoopaCandy

    KoopaCandy Kenkyuusei

    Jun 23, 2009
    Wow, this is tricky! Ranking AKB girls is hard enough. Let me see, currently..

    Top 10

    1. Yoshizawa Hitomi (ex-MM)
    2. Miyazawa Sae (AKB)
    3. Akimoto Sayaka (AKB)
    4. Nakanishi Yuuka (SKE)
    5. Ogawa Makoto (ex-MM)
    6. Masuda Yuka (AKB)
    7. Yaguchi Mari (ex-MM)
    8. Ohtani Masae (Melon Kinenbi)
    9. Amber (f(x))
    10. Hayami Akari (Momoiro Clover)
    Truthfully, I love Sae, Sayaka Nishi and Mako all about the same.. but I didn't want to be super cheap and give them all the same spot, ha ha. And Yossi will always be in the top spot on principle, just because I have her to blame for the whole loving idols thing. <3
  10. kenchanayoh

    kenchanayoh Kenkyuusei Stage48 Donor

    Aug 29, 2010

    1. Seungyeon (KARA)
    2. Taeyeon (SNSD)/Nicole (KARA)
    4. Tomochin (AKB48)
    5. Maachan (AKB48)
    6. Sayumi Michishige (MM)
    7. Risa Niigaki (MM)
    8. Mariko Shinoda (AKB48)
    9. Natsumi Matsubara (AKB48)
    10. Kanon Wakeshima
  11. Tyzer

    Tyzer Member

    Oct 10, 2010
    Australia, Melbourne
    Top 10
    1. Michishige Sayumi (Morning Musume)
    2. Shinoda Mariko (AKB48)
    3. Iida Kaori (Ex-Morning Musume)
    4. Kojima Haruna (AKB48)
    5. Yajima Maimi (C-ute)
    6. Kumai Yurina (Berryz Koubou)
    7. Maeda Atsuko (AKB48)
    8. Itano Tomomi (AKB48)
    9. Minegishi Minami (AKB48)
    10. Kamei Eri (Morning Musume)
  12. yuzuko

    yuzuko Kenkyuusei

    Aug 26, 2010
    Current ranking, will change anytime

    1. Watanabe Mayu (AKB48)
    2. Kashiwagi Yuki (AKB48)
    3. Takahashi Minami (AKB48)
    4. Maeda Yuuka (s/mileage)
    5. Ona Erena (ex-AKB48)
    6. Hashimoto Kaede (Idoling!!!)
    7. Hirajima Natsumi (AKB48)
    8. Mano Erina
    9. Kawashima Umika (9Nine)
    10. Mastui Jurina (SKE48)
  13. blesseddisgrace

    blesseddisgrace Kenkyuusei

    Jun 1, 2010
    I've never actually thought about ranking all of my favorite idols overall, but I'll give it a shot. o:

    Top 10 Idols
    1. Sakurai Sho (Arashi)
    2. Minegishi Minami (AKB48)
    2. Ninomiya Kazunari (Arashi)
    4. Sashihara Rino (AKB48)
    5. Kashiyuka (Perfume)
    6. Okada Junichi (V6)
    7. Aiba Masaki (Arashi)
    8. Kashiwagi Yuki (AKB48)
    9. Aragaki Yui
    10. Oshima Yuko (AKB48)

    er, yeah. Idols aren't my main area of expertise. :B I only really follow AKB and Arashi, although I do like a lot of individual members of other groups that would probably be somewhere in 11-15.
  14. gyan

    gyan Kenkyuusei

    Oct 2, 2007
    AMOCCHINA! (・ω・)ノ
    Seems like a fun thread don't know why there's not many posts,
    My top 10:
    1) Sato Amina (akb48)
    2) Erica Tonooka (idoling!!!) maybe overanking but shes just too hot/cute
    3) Risa Niigaki (morning musume)
    4) Sasshihara Rino (akb48)
    5) Kamei Eri (soon ex morning musume)
    6) Michishige Sayumi (morning musume)
    7) Kuramochi Asuka (akb48)
    8) CL (2NE1)
    9) Hyoyeon (SNSD)
    10) Michelle miki (ex idoling!!!)
    Sigh that was harder than i thought well most likely it can change alot but not so drastically. So many people close to the 10th spot.
  15. Naomi

    Naomi Kenkyuusei Retired Staff

    Oct 11, 2007
    My revised idol ranking, yaaay. Forgot some people.

    01. Yoshizawa Hitomi (Ex-Momusu)
    02. Matsubara Natsumi (AKB48)
    03. Akimoto Sayaka (AKB48)
    04. Ishikawa Rika (Ex-Momusu)
    05. Rainie Yang
    06. Okai Chisato (C-ute)
    07. Matsui Sakiko (AKB48)
    08. Sashihara Rino (AKB48)
    09. Furukawa Airi (SKE48)
    10. Niigaki Risa (Morning Musume)
    11. Kamenashi Kazuya (KAT-TUN)
    12. Tsuji Nozomi (Ex-Momusu)
    13. Hyoyeon (SNSD)
    14. Hara (KARA)
    15. Yuri (SNSD)

    Rainie may not be an "idol", but I luff her, damnit. <3
    The top 4 are my "ultimate" favorites~ I call them F4. *shot* (Well, no, not really. I thought of it just now. 8D)
  16. kenchanayoh

    kenchanayoh Kenkyuusei Stage48 Donor

    Aug 29, 2010
    ^ i didnt know u were a yossie fan! [clap]
  17. milaya

    milaya Kenkyuusei

    Jun 5, 2007
    Since I unfortunately, have lost most of my interest in idols...
    I guess this is a top 10 that wont change much.

    1. Kusumi Koharu (Ex. MM)
    2. Junjun (MM)
    3. Kashiwagi Yuki (AKB48)
    4. Sato Amina (AKB48)
    4. Yoshizawa Hitomi (Ex. MM)
    5. Nishikido Ryo (NEWS)
    6. Yamashita Tomohisa (NEWS)
    7. Takahashi Minami (AKB48)
    8. Ishikawa Rika (Ex. MM)
    9. Kamei Eri (MM)
    10: Tegoshi Yuya (NEWS)
  18. Naomi

    Naomi Kenkyuusei Retired Staff

    Oct 11, 2007
    Yep, she's been my favorite idol for four years. :D I don't talk about her as much as Natsumi, though, so I'm not surprised that people don't know I'm a fan of her. XD

    I'm glad to see other Yossie fans here, too~ :cute:
  19. pinkbohemia

    pinkbohemia Member

    Dec 13, 2009
    Pennsylvania, United States
    I did this a bit ago but I deleted my post because I didn't think it accurately reflected my ranking. So I thought about it & I think this is pretty good:

    1. Matsui Sakiko (AKB48)
    2. Natsuyaki Miyabi (Berryz)
    3. Yokoyama Yui (AKB48)
    4. Tsuji Nozomi (ex-Morning Musume/Minimoni./W)
    5. Michishige Sayumi (Morning Musume)
    6. Ogawa Makoto (ex-Morning Musume)
    7. Kato Tomoko (SKE48)
    8. Kumai Yurina (Berryz)
    9. Takizawa Hideaki (T&S)
    10. Ogawa Saki (S/mileage)
    Keep in mind that Sakiko is my #1 in so many levels. I've never felt the same way about any other idol like I do with Sakiko. She's my ~*oshimen*~ like... lkjg;laj;glajg;ljk. She's the greatest person in the world okay. ;A; I feel very strongly about my love for her. XD That sounds really weird but I can't really articulate it very well. She's just... amazing. An amazing, classy, beautiful woman. She's just... the best. <3
  20. Kay

    Kay Kenkyuusei

    Jun 11, 2010
    Hmm, I guess my Top 3 would be:

    1.) Yaguchi Mari (ex. Morning Musume)
    2.) Arashi (Although my fav member is Sakurai Sho, I really love all their personalities too much to split them up.)
    3.) Mano Erina

    Although, I really love Idols and Idol groups, the only Idol I follow to the ends of the earth is Yagu-chan. I really consider her the only 'Idol' in my life. A lot of other Idols I love, but not to the same extent that I love Yagu-chan. I can't really pick any members from AKB yet because I'm still so new to the group (I can now name 4 members! Yay!). Maybe, in a year or so, I'll post an updated list if this thread is still around...


Share This Page