Stage48 Countdown: Episode 237 (Members who are too pure for this world)

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Sashihara Rino
3. Kodama Haruka (I like her cute voice, but no to her vocal (singing))
4. Nozawa Rena
5. Yokoyama Yui
6. Matsui Rena (Honestly I love her voice. But I don't think that's not enough for the quality of an idol)
7. Watanabe Miyuki (Same as Rena)
8. Matsumura Kaori
9. Kitagawa Ryoha
10. Shimazaki Haruka (Her voice is just too cute)

 

1. Kojima Natsuki
2. Miyawaki sakura
3. Tomonaga mio
4. Cindy Yuvia
5. Ichikawa miori
6. Sashihara rino
7.muto tomu
8. Watanabe miyuki
9. Yamada nana
10. Nozawa rena

 

1.Tomonaga Mio
2.Kato Minami
3.Muto Tomu
4.Ichikawa Miori
5.Kojima Natsuki
6.Kitahara Rie
7.Miyawaki Sakura
8.Nozawa Rena
9.Matsui Rena
10.Watanabe Miyuki

 

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Sashihara Rino
3. Miyawaki Sakura
4. Serina
5. Fuchigami Mai

Mai is far away from the rest of the the list tho, but the rules say top 5

 

I don't usually give reasons but this kind of deserves one.

01. Kojima Natsuki - I humbly direct you to the last episode of Ante Dare where she sang with Aaya and Wakanyan. Just as one example... of many...
02. Okawa Rio - I recently caught a Team 4 stage. Her vocals were .... not good. At all.
03. Nozawa Rena - I'm sure she is still trying to improve... hopefully...
04. Tashima Meru - unpopular opinion but I dislike her voice more than Mio's, and the Einstein Yori song just cemented that for me.
05. Oshima Mai - this may seem like a random grad, but her solos are awful. AWFUL.
06. Suda Akari - combine her voice with Kaotan's, and it's not too bad. On its own though...
07. Matsui Jurina - Glory days. Akai Pinheel. CHICKEN LINE. Ok not so much Akai Pinheel, but it's not the best voice.
08. Tomonaga Mio - I think she has improved, but Einstein Yori showed it hadn't improved enough.
09. Kodama Haruka - given the right song her voice isn't too bad, but Taboo no Iro stands out in my mind as a bad example.
10. Miyawaki Sakura - her voice is flat; it can be cute, given the right song, which she rarely is. Wimbledon and Taboo no Iro as examples.

 

1.Tomonaga Mio
2. Kojima Natsuki
3. Muto Tomu
4. Kato Minami
5. Matsui Jurina
6. Watanabe Miyuki (but I like her Boku wa Inai solo line )
7. Yamada Nana
8. Shimazaki Haruka
9. Kitatagawa Ryoha
10. Miyawaki Sakura

Sent with Tapatalk

 

1.Tomonaga mio
2.Nozawa Rena
3.Miyawaki Sakura
4.Kato Minami
5.Kojima Natsuki
6.Sashihara Rino
7.Watanabe Miyuki
8.Matsui Jurina
9.Muto Tomu
10.Suda Akari

 

1.Kojima Natsuki
2.Nozawa Rena
3.Ikoma Rina
4.Akimoto Manatsu
5.Tomonaga Mio
6.Muto Tomu
7.Kitahara Rie
8.Miyawaki Sakura
9.Suda Akari
10.Watanabe Miyuki

 

1. Kojima Natsuki
2. Tomonaga Mio
3. Muto Tomu
4. Nozawa Rena
5. Fuchigami Mai
6. Miyawaki Sakura
7. Oshima Mai
8. Okawa Rio
9. Suda Akari
10. Watanabe Miyuki

 

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Kojima Natsuki
3. Shimazaki Haruka
4. Nozawa Rena
5. Miyawaki Sakura
6. Sutou Ririka
7. Matsumura Kaori
8. Sashihara Rino
9. Suda Akari
10. Kato Minami

 

Hey! Tomu may not have a great singing voice or strong technique, but she at least sings on key!! LOL

 

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Matsumura Sayuri (i love her but when I heard Muhyoujou I cringed)
3. Akimoto Manatsu
4. Nozawa Rena
5. Matsumura Kaori
6. Tanaka Yuka (something in her voice is not good at all but idk what it is)
7. Okawa Rio
8. Kojima Natsuki
9. Ikoma Rina
10. Kato Minami (She's my NGT oshi but her voice is a no no)

 

1. Kojima Natsuki
2. Tomonaga Mio
3. Ikoma Rina
4. Shimazaki Haruka
5. Miyawaki Sakura
6. Muto Tomu
7. Miyawaki Sakura
8. Akimoto Manatsu
9. Sashihara Rino
10. Kato Minami

 

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Kitahara Rie
3. Miyawaki Sakura
4. Kodama Haruka
5. Muto Tomu
6. Matsui Jurina
7. Sashihara Rino
8. Ikoma Rina
9. Shimazaki Haruka
10. Matsui Rena

 

1. Akimoto Manatsu
2. Tomonaga Mio
3. Ikoma Rina
4. Miyawaki Sakura
5. Shimazaki Haruka
6. Sashihara Rino
7-8. WMatsui (have no idea who is over another.)
9. Kodama Haruka
10. Muto Tomu

 

1. Kojima Natsuki
2. Oshima Mai
3. Tomonaga Mio
4. Kodama Haruka
5. Serina
6. Okawa Rio
7. Nozawa Rena
8. Kitahara Rie
9. Hashimoto Nanami
10. Tanabe Miku

I'm curious if people have seen Tomu's recent lives. I know she is far of being Masuda Yuka but she doesn't go offkey. I just find her tone...weak, but pleasant with the right songs (Hajimari no Yuki for example).

 

1. Tomonaga Mio
2. Miyawaki Sakura
3. Watanabe Miyuki
4. Kojima Haruna
5. Shimazaki Haruka
6. Sashihara Rino
7. Iriyama Anna
8. Yokoyama Yui
9. Takakura Moeka
10. Tashima Meru

 

It might have been a bad day for her or something, she's in the upper half of Nogizaka in terms of singing (IMO better than someone's oshimen who is not to be found on that list just kidding of course)

 

@oji-sama I think so! I'm curious to listen her new solo, because it truly surprised me for her and Nanamin