Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed TAKAMINAAAA CONGRATULATION [party] [party] I am glad that she is dominating our hearts for 3 years in a row, no wonder that her thread has the most pages maybe in any foriegn website or forum. I wish we can have a way to let her know about this result, maybe we can print a board & someone give it to her or her manager or TGSK & then hand it to her, & I want her to be happy through these many stress situation that she went through at the past months. Gongratulation for the "Queen of Stage48" And here is my votes: Spoiler 01. Takahashi Minami (+15) 02. Iwasa Misaki (+10) 03. Anai Chihiro (+9) 04. Watanabe Mayu (+8) 05. Kawaei Rina (+7) 06. Maeda Atsuko (+6) 07. Oshima Yuko (+5) 08. Kinoshita Momoka (+5) 09. Iwata Karen (+4) 10. Yamamoto Sayaka (+4) 11. Takahashi Juri (+4) 12. Jonishi Kei (+3) 13. Tano Yuka (+3) 14. Ogasawara Mayu (+3) 15. Miyawaki Sakura (+2) 16. Yakata Miki (+2) 17. Shimazaki Haruka (+2) 18. Suda Akari (+1) 19. Matsui Rena (+1) 20. Kotani Riho (+1) & there is no negative points [shake]
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Woah, Takamina going three years strong! She's got the hearts of Stage48 on lock! [party] For the people who are wondering why she got down-voted: I assume it was nothing against her personally, it was just an attempt to bring her down a rank so the top rank could be filled by their oshi. Btw I didn't down vote her so don't attack me, I'm just guessing!
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Congrats my bb I knew she was going to win If this was the real election... Congratulations to Yuuchan and Mayuchan and everyone as well
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed TOMOCHIN TOP 5 YEAH!!! This rank made my day man Here's my votes tho.. Spoiler 01. MEMBER NAME (+15) Itano Tomomi 02. MEMBER NAME (+10) Takahashi Minami 03. MEMBER NAME (+9) Kojima Haruna 04. MEMBER NAME (+8) Shinoda Mariko 05. MEMBER NAME (+7) Maeda Atsuko 06. MEMBER NAME (+6) Minegishi Minami 07. MEMBER NAME (+5) Oshima Yuko 08. MEMBER NAME (+5) Miyazawa Sae 09. MEMBER NAME (+4) Akimoto sayaka 10. MEMBER NAME (+4) Watanabe Mayu 11. MEMBER NAME (+4) Matsui Rena 12. MEMBER NAME (+3) Kitahara Rie 13. MEMBER NAME (+3) Kashiwagi Yuki 14. MEMBER NAME (+3) Yokoyama Yui 15. MEMBER NAME (+2) Kasai Tomomi 16. MEMBER NAME (+2) Umeda Ayaka 17. MEMBER NAME (+2) Ichikawa Miori 18. MEMBER NAME (+1) Kuramochi Asuka 19. MEMBER NAME (+1) Iwata Karen 20. MEMBER NAME (+1) Maeda Ami no neg votes.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Mariko Sama!!!! Top 10. Shall continue later.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed thanks for the hard work ithebigc!! looking at how far mayuyu to oshima yuko, I could say that yuko is "Godlike".. but soukantoku is "Beyond Godlike" and WMatsui have the same exact amount of voters.. 60/5. [shock] damn coincidence..
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Yay...! i'm glad to see Sayaka's rank.. and i'm the only one who vote Kobayashi kana here's my list Spoiler 01. Akimoto Sayaka (+15) 02. Ohori Megumi (+10) 03. Oshima Yuko (+9) 04. Matsubara Natsumi (+8) 05. Kobayashi kana (+7) 06. Masuda Yuka (+6) 07. Maeda Atsuko (+5) 08. Nakagawa Haruka (+5) 09. Miyazawa Sae (+4) 10. Chikano Rina (+4) 11. Kojima Haruna (+4) 12. Takahashi Minami (+3) 13. Shinoda Mariko (+3) 14. Nonaka Misato (+3) 15. Matsui Sakiko (+2) 16. Sato Natsuki (+2) 17. Minegishi Minami (+2) 18. Sato Amina (+1) 19. Yokoyama Yui (+1) 20. Matsui Jurina (+1) [party]
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Her name is quite famous here for the tallent she got I think the reason is a lot appreciate her but she is just not placed in their kami oshi spot, making them barely visit the thread unless something is rly necessary to be shout off. ------ There must've been a tons of work put in calculating them. Thanks to the staffs who've made this awesome event lol, I am bit surprised that somebody downvote Takamina even when it doesn't rly affect her point I am curious with the reason too. Maybe because Takamina was being too hard on somebody? Hopefully in the next event my oshi will make it higher than she is
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed she will always be my number one congratulations for the top 3 espescially for Takamina for her hattrick really glad for Yuko too here's my list Spoiler 01. Matsui Jurina (+15) 02. Yamamoto Sayaka (+10) 03. Matsui Rena (+9) 04. Oshima Yuko (+8) 05. Kimoto Kanon (+7) 06. Beby Chaesara Anadila (+6) 07. Sato Amina (+5) 08. Watanabe Mayu (+5) 09. Watanabe Miyuki (+4) 10. Miyawaki Sakura (+4) 11. Takahashi MInami (+4) 12. Iriyama Anna (+3) 13. Kawaei Rina (+3) 14. Takahashi Juri (+3) 15. Nakagawa Haruka (+2) 16. Takajo Aki (+2) 17. Kashiwagi Yuki (+2) 18. Devi Kinal Putri (+1) 19. Rezky Wiranti Dhike (+1) 20. Jessica Veranda (+1) Spoiler big mistake ! i just realize that i've forgot to vote Meru
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed So what happened with Tomochin negative votes compared to past couple of years? 2012: 5. (11) [53|2] Itano Tomomi {+334,-3}, 331 2011: 11. [ 33 | 15 ] Itano Tomomi (+225, -50) 175 2010: 17. [ 18 | 13 ] Itano Tomomi (+156, -48) 108 Also happy about her positive votes - clear progress and this year it doesn't include "graduation sympathy" votes because voting was closed before her announcement. Thank you ithebigc for your titanic effort. I almost half jokingly asked about why not to do 2012 voting and you immediately jumped into action. Now I feel guilty about voting against your fav girl.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed I guess people realized that Itano is actually a nice kind girl, instead of actually being this cool girl with a b****y attitude.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed I will push Karen-chan, Murashige and Sakura-chan. That was the plan... I have no idea what Watanabe Miyuki is doing there. >< 01. Iwata Karen (+15) 02. Murashige Anna (+10) 03. Watanabe Miyuki (+9) 04. Miyawaki Sakura (+8) 05. Maeda Ami (+7) 06. Oya Shizuka (+6) 07. Yokoyama Yui (+5) 08. Shimada Haruka (+5) 09. Minegishi Minami (+4) 10. Hirata Rina (+4) 11. Oshima Yuko (+4) 12. Iwasa Misaki (+3) 13. Takeuchi Miyu (+3) 14. Yamauchi Suzuran (+3) 15. Suda Akari (+2) 16. Kinoshita Momoka (+2) 17. Yamamoto Sayaka (+2) 18. Nito Moeno (+1) 19. Kojima Haruna (+1) 20. Matsui Sakiko (+1) 01. Shimazaki Haruka (-5) 02. Tashima Meru (-4) Members with good (singing...) abilities, members who I like, members who are less popular, members that are active are pushed up on this list. (aka not Karen is my favorite) Popular members are pushed down because I thought many people would have them on the upper part of their lists, so those members don't really need even more points from me. As for the negative points, I like seeing Haruka in magazines, she was funny in the documentary +10+1 but her current position within the group is just wrong. It sends a negative message to the other members and her "I don't give a fuck, I'm ponkotsu" mentality doesn't help either. She is not a naturally selected member of this group for the center position (or nowhere near). And It's annoying that the management uses her ponkotsu character to damp the negative reactions that her forced push generates (and she is okay with it). I'm sure that the casual AKB fans in Japan are not interested in these kind of things so Paruru will receive many votes in the next Election though... Meru is the little Paruru in HKT. If we had been able to vote for Aki-P (as the management) I would have gave him -5 and just -4 to Paruru btw.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed As for my top 5. Except for Amina, everyone got negatives which was the name of the game for them. Had I replaced Amina with Paruru, my top 5 could have been the worst 5 based on negatives alone. Takamina won again as expected. Yuko and Mayuyu were in a noticeable gap but still managed to bag 2nd and 3rd respectively. Yukirin got a big jump and I guess this was good. Sakuratan ranking high to lead HKT. Milky getting negatives and so does Miichan and Yuko. At least the negatives were given to the people that a lot of people know by name. Iwata Karen getting a good score so this is a surprise.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed At last the top10... ...Takamina? She's the S48 Queen again (and Yuko the princess ), I'm not surprised at all. Congratulations!! [clap] Perhaps we should change the name of the forum...STaka48? ...Miichan. A bit disappointing. I expected she would lose one spot to Mayuyu, but I didn't expect she would lose two spots more. Well, after all, Yukirin, Mayu and Yuko were the top3 of the last senbatsu election, so I guess it makes sense. And Tomochin is one of my oshis, so I can't complain about it (although the evolution of her positive and negative votes is quite surprising... :dunno: ) ...IMHO, It has been clearly shown (again) that most of the stagers fall into one of these two categories, those who vote mostly for members of the sisters groups and have only a few members (or none at all) from AB48 in their lists...and those who vote mostly for AKB48 members and seldom vote for members of the sister groups apart from Jurina and Rena. My votes: Spoiler 01. Minegishi Minami (+15) 02. Umeda Ayaka (+10) 03. Itano Tomomi (+9) 04. Kinoshita Yukiko (+8) 05. Watanabe Miyuki (+7) 06. Sato Sumire (+6) 07. Kasai Tomomi (+5) 08. Oshima Yuko (+5) 09. Yokoyama Yui (+4) 10. Maeda Ami (+4) 11. Takahashi Minami (+4) 12. Kikuchi Ayaka (+3) 13. Chikano Rina (+3) 14. Shinoda Mariko (+3) 15. Kashiwagi Yuki (+2) 16. Takayanagi Akane (+2) 17. Iwata Karen (+2) 18. Matsui Sakiko (+1) 19. Matsui Rena (+1) 20. Nito Moeno (+1) I didn't use the negative votes. However, if someone is really interested to know what I would have voted... Spoiler ... I guess that my 'targets' would have been Mayuyu, Paruru, Miorin, Sasshi...and Abemaru
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Good stuff all around. Spoiler 01. Oshima Yuko(+15) 02. Takahashi Minami (+10) 03. Yokoyama Yui (+9) 04. Kojima Haruna (+8) 05. Kashiwagi Yuki (+7) 06. Umeda Ayaka (+6) 07. Itano Tomomi (+5) 08. Kuramochi Asuka (+5) 09. Kasai Tomomi (+4) 10. Akimoto Sayaka (+4) 11. Sato Amina (+4) 12. Tano Yuka (+3) 13. Ichikawa Miori (+3) 14. Maeda Atsuko (+3) 15. Minegishi Minami (+2) 16. Miyazawa Sae (+2) 17. Shinoda Mariko (+2) 18. Nakagawa Haruka (+1) 19. Uchida Mayumi (+1) 20. Yamamoto Sayaka (+1) 01. Sashihara Rino (-5) Nothing too exciting on my list. Miichan would be off my list if her incident happened in within the voting timeframe.
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Spoiler Theres a post here that I'd want to reply, but then again, I doubt the post is worth me losing energy over anyways, so I'm just going to add that person to my blocklist. Good day to that person. That aside, cheers to Rena for entering the Top 7, pity I didn't vote for her nor any other member - the other positions are kinda standard...not very interesting tbh [speechless] Anyways, since I didn't wanted to vote, I guess i'll post what I would've voted had I wanted to: Spoiler 01. Matsui Rena(+15) 02. Kashiwagi Yuki (+10) 03. Oshima Yuko (+9) 04. Miyazawa Sae (+8) 05. Matsui Jurina (+7) 06. Kojima Haruna (+6) 07. Kitahara Rie (+5) 08. Watanabe Mayu (+5) 09. Abe Maria (+4) 10. Yokoyama Yui (+4) 11. Akimoto Sayaka (+4) 12. Tashima Meru (+3) 13. Shimazaki Haruka (+3) 14. Takahashi Juri (+3) 15. Shinoda Mariko (+2) 16. Takajo Aki (+2) 17. Matsumura Sayuri (+2) 18. Sashihara Rino (+1) 19. Nakanishi Yuka (+1) 20. Watanabe Miyuki (+1) Not really much reasoning tbh, just going by how much I liked the member and their appeal to me - and yes, Meru already caught my attention then to warrant her a (+3), not that it mattered much anyways considering any vote below (+4) meant the members appealed to me by just a bit (yes, that includes Paruru)
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Congrats to Takamina! Not surprising at all. Although I'm kind of shocked someone gave her a negative vote. And I fully think the negative votes should be included...it's just, with Takamina, it seems somewhat sacrilegious! Also, wow, Karen! Who knew? It's interesting that some folks had a strategy when they ranked, to give higher point values to less popular girls to 'push' them in their own way. I like that! I wish I'd altered my ranking a bit to push my SKE faves a bit more. My own list: Spoiler 01. Matsui Jurina (+15) Thanks for the hard work, ithebigc. [clap]
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Takamina, Yuko, Mayuyu are highest, Paruru and Sasshi got a lot of hates, it's so predictable . My only surprise is Sae and Akicha are so low. They are so-called "international" members and they rank surprisingly low for an international forum like S48. My votes: Spoiler 01. SATO AMINA (+15) 02. TAKEUCHI MIYU (+10) 03. KIKUCHI AYAKA (+9) 04. MINEGISHI MINAMI (+8) 05. AKIMOTO SAYAKA (+7) 06. MATSUI SAKIKO (+6) 07. YOKOYAMA YUI (+5) 08. SHIMADA HARUKA (+5) 09. UMEDA AYAKA (+4) 10. OSHIMA YUKO (+4) 11. MUTO TOMU (+4) 12. ICHIKAWA MIORI (+3) 13. OGISO SHIORI (+3) 14. OBA MINA (+3) 15. YAMADA NANA (+2) 16. KURAMOCHI ASUKA (+2) 17. MIYAWAKI SAKURA (+2) 18. JO ERIKO (+1) 19. KATAYAMA HARUKA (+1) 20. OYA SHIZUKA (+1)
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed Spoiler I so glad Soukantoku won again! Also happy how high Miichan was
Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed I think that is exactly what happened. Sayaka used to get a healthy amount of negative votes on this forum as well. I think that was less about Sayaka and more about the fact that there used to be quite a few uber-aggressive Sayaka fans in here. But Sayaka wins out (no negatives) for simply being a good idol.
