The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

People who I voted for!

Spoiler

01. Yamada Erika (+15)
02. Eto Sayaka (+10)
03. Fuchigami Mai (+9)
04. Nakada Kana (+8)
05. Fujita Nana (+7)
06. Yamamoto Hitomi (+6)
07. Matsuda Shiori (+5)
08. Motomura Aoi (+5)
09. Kitahara Rie (+4)
10. Yamamoto Sayaka (+4)
11. Ishikawa Kokoro (+4)
12. Sasaki Nanami (+3)
13. Yamashita Yukari (+3)
14. Shimazaki Haruka (+3)
15. Nagao Mariya (+2)
16. Okamoto Naoko (+2)
17. Tani Marika (+2)
18. Futamura Haruka (+1)
19. Maeda Ami (+1)
20. Akiyoshi Yuka (+1)

This was really fun to see all the results of the members coming along together day by day. :3

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

I can't believe I'm just now noticing this but WOW at Sasshi not being in the top 100 and having such a low score. I guess the casual fans of Sasshi left after what happened probably...or people must really hate her...or both. [think]

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

it's not close to paruru hate, but yeah....why so much hate on sasshi? She has a vivid personnality which make her so enjoyable to see on variety show. Other member are so boring compared to her. This is the same aura as miichan.

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

It prob has less to do with her than her scandals. Sashi is prob one of the most entertaining girl in the groups but her scandals and the fact she isn't really pretty prob is what brought her down. I find her hilarious in the HKT shows and actually look forward to seeing her MC.

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

I don't find scandals to have much impact here. Paruru never has a scandal as far as we know and most of us here do not really care how many bf Sasshi have as shown in the No-Dating-Law thread .

IMO, there are two reasons. First, Sasshi is the first member outside the old gens joining the Kami level. Paruru is likely to be the second and is on the way to be center as well. Fans of old gen feel threatened. Fans of other members are upset that their oshis are not pushed enough. We can call this inertia . Second, both Sasshi and Paruru have a "unique" personality, hetare and ponkotsu, respectively . In other words, they both are untalented and publicly admit they are untalented.
Heavily pushed + Untalented = Hated

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

With Sasshi in my case it wasn't about what she did, but how she handled it afterwards.
Now when Miichan have set a new standard, Sasshis actions looked especially weak. With western background I might not understand the rules. But if there is a group of people willingly operating under same rules in order to reach common goal and if one individual breaks it without even showing considerable regret?!?
Well, that is pretty clearly understandable no matter where you are on this planet. It's one of the human civilization progress cornerstones.

 

Re: The 2012 Stage48 Member Ranking Results (Top 10 Revealed

As Takamina's thread leads the forum in terms of post count and views, its a result I expected, just a lot of people follow that thread.

Somehow, we could attribute the fact that her old critics in the forum have been inactive or at the other forums. For the past year, though there were some members dissing her, they were too few to make an effective effort.