The 2017 Stage48 Member Ranking

@Slacker13 we're not really supposed to share our votes until the voting period has ended and we get to see the list. You'll have enough time to give your reasons why you voted the way you did when time comes

I have to admit I'm more curious to see who got negative points and the reasonings for that. I never feel compelled to give negative points to anyone

 

You guys do care about me.Haha.I'll be careful from now on then.

 

i really want to vote so bad...
but what can i do, i only have one post (2 with this) so far after all these years joined in this forum
if i given a chance, my ranking would look like this :

Spoiler: My Top 20 Favourite Members

Yokoyama Yui
Okabe Rin
Kojima Mako
Taniguchi Megu
Murayama Yuiri
Sato Shiori T8
Shimizu Maria
Honda Hitomi
Asai Nanami
Yamauchi Mizuki
Taguchi Manaka
Nishikawa Rei
Kubo Satone
Cho Kurena
Yoshikawa Nanase
Omori Miyu
Iwatate Saho
Oda Erina
Sakaguchi Nagisa
Hiwatashi Yui

--------------------------------------------

Spoiler: dislike list

matsui jurina
sashihara rino
matsuoka hana
suda akari
matsumura kaori

 

If only there is a laugh reaction...
Man, their child's name has a nice ring

 

please count the votes of this guy

 

don't worry, no one will ever read his lengthy, unstructured rant(s) XD. Unless those people want to spin their head around lol.

 

Oh Hey @bonjourmarlene AND @souchan48 are we getting "personal" again soo soon??

I typed "1" sentence stating that I merely VOTED...never mentioned "WHO" in the 2017 Stage Ranking...then as I read further I realized I was 'Unclear' in the 2nd line dealing with Hirate Yurina as to WHEN I vote Miss Hirate #10. That was LAST YEAR's list I was commenting on. I mistakenly assumed people realized it was LAST YEAR. I'm gonna edit that now. Thanks for being a Fan! I know you'll always read my 'Stuff' & chime in. It's what makes me so "special".

I remember the year Sayurin NGZK46 came in 'DEAD LAST'- just mathmatically because of "Negatives" 6 months after that Bunshun deal. Every year there are surprises in the Stage48 ranking...it's what makes it so interesting.

SLACKER Trivia:

Spoiler

WHO has been on my "Naughty List" Most? (in MY past rankings). You'd never guess who- You might get a Prize!

 

Thanks for your support, man
(Now 3 with this post )

 

I wasn't being personal, I was simply saying that it says in the original post we shouldn't reveal anything until the votes have been counted (because I did not realise you were talking about last year). Sorry if you considered it a personal attack. We definitely don't see eye-to-eye on a lot of topics, our numerous private conversations prove that, but I'm not one of those people that dislike or disagree with a post just because of the person who posted it. My second sentence about having enough time to talk about the results was also not sarcastic. I really thought you were talking about this year's voting and that you were already, like, defending your reasons. It's probably gonna be more interesting to talk about it when the lists are revealed because then more people will be here as well

Also, I'm guessing Miichan might be one of the people on your naughty list?

 

Why would you even...
It's really saddening to see there are people like this... I wonder why you don't like her...

 

@ithebigc
Also quick correction under NMB48 Team N

It's Azuma Yuki not Azuma Yuka.

 

I made a perfectly good DM explaining why. It's all water under the bridge - it's no big deal. Like I'd waste a (-5) on Takamina. But I can say her taking 16 months to graduation has something to do w/ it.

@bonjourmarlene - is that your final answer? Every year I know this person will be on my "Naughty" list. It's easy to find in those older threads.

 

Maby we should hold another rank for „the most annoying menagement decisions” so people won’t release fustration on innocent members

 

Well this can just be my thinking and opinion, but the reason/s why some dislike a certain member might not only be management decisions. There can be other stuff that bothers, like how they express themselves
on TV-shows, possible interviews or even fan-events (I know it's super-rare but had to mention.) Or it can be just a single word, phrase or act which got stuck in a fan's mind in a negative way.

 

Agree with that, I think that everybody has some public person they dislike, but it’s important to divide this two diffrent kinds of dissliking. I don’t think that “taking 16 months to graduation” is a reason to give somebody a negative vote

 

He can vote like that if he wants, but we can also silently judge him as a person.

And anyways I'm calling Rikachan to be the queen of haters on this forum as I know a bunch of people is going to downvote her for multiple various reasons.

The title is rightfully befitting to her anyways

 

People hating on Rika are pitiful. Why would you hate on someone who went from 24/24 to 11/41 in a year?

 

But wasn't (most of) the (reasons of) hate for Rikachan happened in 2018? Or I just don't remember much of what happened in 2017. And we are adviced not to negative rank for something out of her control (mgmt pushes, center, solo, agency). Is it her wailing on showroom or roasting 'haters'? I imagine her negative points will be much higher for the 2018 ranking.