Love your reply XD Personally, I'm neither a fan nor a hater of Nakai. I was not a fan of her push though.
And to be fair. Nakai got the least negative votes of all the NGT bottom 6, she just didn’t get as many positives as Ogiyuka.
Only one member revealed from my votes so far. 01. MEMBER NAME (+15) 02. MEMBER NAME (+10) 03. MEMBER NAME (+9) 04. MEMBER NAME (+8) 05. MEMBER NAME (+7) 06. MEMBER NAME (+6) 07. MEMBER NAME (+5) 08. MEMBER NAME (+5) 09. MEMBER NAME (+4) 10. MEMBER NAME (+4) 11. MEMBER NAME (+4) 12. MEMBER NAME (+3) 13. MEMBER NAME (+3) 14. 419. (---) [1|0] [HKT] Baba Sayaka {+3,0}, 3 15. MEMBER NAME (+2) 16. MEMBER NAME (+2) 17. MEMBER NAME (+2) 18. MEMBER NAME (+1) 19. MEMBER NAME (+1) 20. MEMBER NAME (+1) Seems I was the only one who appreciated this cutie enough to vote her. Thought Seki Ai was gonna be my fave D3 from HKT. Then the D3's started performing stages in the theater. And Baba ran far ahead of the other four three.
My ranking now: 01. ?? (+15) 02. ?? (+10) 03. ?? (+9) 04. ?? (+8) 05. ?? (+7) 06. ?? (+6) 07. ?? (+5) 08. ?? (+5) 09. ?? (+4) 10. ?? (+4) 11. ?? (+4) 12. ?? (+3) 13. ?? (+3) 14. ?? (+3) 15. ?? (+2) 16. ?? (+2) 17. ?? (+2) 18. ?? (+1) 19. 470. (---) [1|0] [NGT] Ando Chikana {+1,0}, 1 I'm sad I'm the only who voted for her... I liked her since AKB48 Group 3rd SHOWROOM's streams, before she entered in NGT. I was happy when she was chosen as a NGT member but now I think she had bad luck... 20. ?? (+1) Negative points: 01. 506. (27) [5|30] [NGT] Kato Minami {+20,-103}, -83 02. 505. (60) [2|17] [NGT] Yamada Noe {+7,-34}, -27 03. 508. (131) [0|31] [NGT] Tano Ayaka {+0,-125}, -125 04. 503. (15) [7|25] [NGT] Ogino Yuka {+49,-61}, -12 05. 502. (212) [0|2] [NGT] Sato Anju {+0,-2}, -2 Of course my negative points go to NGT48 members. Btw, I was surprised when I saw the drop of Sayaya. She is not in my 20 list but I feel bad for her... 444. (140) [1|0] [AKB] Kawamoto Saya {+2,0}, 2
444. (---) [1|0] [MNL] Ruther Marie Lingat {+2,0}, 2 470. (---) [1|0] [BNK] Chanyapuk Numprasop {+1,0}, 1 470. (338) [1|0] [BNK] Patchanan Jiajirachote {+1,0}, 1 470. (---) [1|0] [SGO] Châu Ngọc Đoan Thảo {+1,0}, 1 Well, I'm the only one who voted for these girls . New and Orn are caught me by their visual, while Hikari really stand out for me because she is an AKB48 for a long time and Ruth for being a quite good MC. Out of 5 girls I have given negative votes, 4 of them have appeared and I will reveal my negative list once the only girl left in my negative list had appeared in the ranking .
01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. Michieda Saki (+3) 15. 16. Kitano Ruka (+2) 17. 18. 19. 20. Well I'm glad I voted for them lol. I think Sakipon is a really charming performer, reminds me of Kojiharu. I don't understand why she's still a kenkyuusei. I guess a lot of SKEs dropped this time based on those stats. I hope Ruka doesn't graduate though or I'm going to have all of like 2 at most I like.
For Izone it was tough to decide between all members and just the Japanese members. I figured including them would be the least unpopular course. Their fans seem fairly active here. I don't even follow Yoshimotozaka but you'd probably be surprised at how idolly they are. They're not a once off novelty group as they already released their second single recently. They do handshake events and are all genuinely celebrities. They have some girls popular on the site, especially the two former NMB members. And finally Hinatazaka are officially referred to as the 4th Sakamichi group, after Yoshimotozaka.
I think it made sense, Izone had a lot of involvement with AKI-P and does Japanese promos and all that. It seems pretty close to a sister group.
Spoiler: Positives [HIDE] [/HIDE] Spoiler: Negatives [HIDE] Nishigata Marina (-5) to me, she seems to be the instigator of everything. First time I actually gave negative votes Tano Ayaka (-4) would have given her -5 as well if possible Kato Minami (-3) initially, I had just taken her off my list of favourites but after the instagram story, I really started to despise her Yamada Noe (-2) even if the mocking wasn't of any ill intent, it was gross and disrespectful Ogino Yuka (-1) the fact she kept hanging out with Marina and Ayaka after everything that's happened and felt untouchable made me really dislike her [/HIDE]
Spoiler Until now: 16. 444. (---) [1|0] [SKE] Kataoka Narumi {+2,0}, 2 and 18. 419. (280) [2|0] [SKE] Aikawa Honoka {+3,0}, 3 I'm glad there's someone out there who voted for Honono~ Sadly, I made the ranking in such a hurry I completely forgot to add negative votes for the ngt members but there's next year (hopefully)
Well I am personally very interested to see where all the IZ*ONE girls rank because let's say a lot of my votes went to them lol.
I was hoping the stage48 member ranking will be held next year as well (I'm pretty sure if @kanjo didn't take the initiative, we wouldn't have the ranking this year), so I could get the chance to express my disapproval of their behavior; I was not hoping for even more reasons to cast negative votes, although now that I'm reading my previous comment I can see how easily it can be misinterpreted. I should have been more clear.
Point taken, let's just hope they see the writing on the wall and remove themselves from next year's member ranking ... or better yet, someone else decides that when all the dust has settled .. to quietly (or not) kick them out or shunt them into some dead end career
Even if they graduate tomorrow they'll still be in it because they were active in 2019. But they'll probably save themselves a few negatives if they do leave tomorrow. Spoiler yes, I realise the ranking is just for fun, and the ngt girls aren't crying over their ranks
01. 02. 03. 04. 05. 06. 07. 08. 09. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. Fujizono Rei (+2) 16. 17. 18. Ito Kirara (+1) 19. 20. 470. (---) [1|0] [AKB] Ito Kirara {+1,0}, 1 well well well, I'm very disappointed with all of you eito "fans"! where are you all when she is at the lowest point of her idol life? 419. (---) [2|0] [AKB] Fujizono Rei {+3,0}, 3 thanks for the +1 @Aka she is lil bit at lost right now but I'm sure she will be back at the right track soon that's what I want to believe. since she is the last eito that we have
it's her own doing, although I still suspect it was Nagi who suggested that hairstyle and eating habits and she still ranked better than last year! even if she does I have to say I'm far from being a fan of her way of talking. Very draaaawwwwly. you all got so played, never listening to me