[RANKING] The SKE48 Ranking Thread

I don't really know all of the girls well enough to properly rank all of them beyond say, my top 10. I like everyone in SKE48 so most of those who are not listed are because I just don't know them at all more so than not liking them or anything like that.

Above all, my #1 will probably always be Rena. Below that, they're a little more random beyond the groupings.

I'm usually a sucker for genki:

2. Churi: Former introvert? Would never have guessed.
3. Akarin: It's hard to describe what I exactly like about her. She tries hard and sometimes makes a fool out of herself, but seems like she can laugh at herself when she does. That's a plus in my book.
4. Umechan: You can definitely tell she used to be a cheerleader. You can also tell that she thinks too fast for her own good.. she needs to remember to breath sometimes when she's MCing.
5. Airi - She's not genki, but she also doesn't belong below either. She's, just.. Airi. I suppose she does get a little genki when anime comes up in conversation.

The rest of these girls have stuck out to me for various reasons, but not enough to rank them higher than the previous 4.

6. Kizaki Yuria: I like how she doesn't seem to take herself too seriously and can laugh at herself
7. Koboyashi Ami: She doesn't get much attention, but something about her look makes her stand out in my mind even though her appearances outside of the background are very few and far between.
8. Mukaida Manatsu: Similar reasoning. She's cute as all.
9. Isohara Kyoka: Her performances on the smaller units she performs in are great. Junjou Shugi is great. I also REALLY like the way she does her hair now, makes her look a little bit less like a 16 year old (even if she is ;/). I don't see her talk in MCs much, but I haven't watched many Team E stages yet either.
10. Hara Minami: She's definitely the one who makes Junjou Shugi better than Team B's rendition in my book, although that's not to say Kyon-chan and Yumana aren't important.

These two probably wouldn't make any top 10 or 20 list (especially since one of them is getting ready to graduate), but I feel like i should mention them because these two are the ones that I would come closest to "disliking" but they eventually won me over.

- Jurina Matsui: I have to admit the reason I "disliked" (more like resentment, really) her in the first place had nothing to do with her but everything to do with the perceived attention that she had seemed to draw away from Rena. Looking at her beyond that, she's an awesome person, deserves every bit of recognition she has, and I wish I was more like her when I was 11. I'm honestly interested to see where she's at in 3-4 years and hope I'm still into 48G by then.
- Kuwabara Mizuki: She seemed overbearing at first, almost un-idol like. Eventually she began to feel like something different from everyone trying to act cute (not that I'm against cute, of course) all the time, and by the time I finished watching RH2013 I decided she was actually a pretty cool person. Just sucks that I decided that after she said she was going to graduate.

 

Removed the graduated girls from my ranking. I will miss Kuumin and Mizuki so much.

 

Plucking the names from my ALL48 -

-------------------
Yagami Kumi
-------------------

Suda Akari
Takayanagi Akane
Matsui Rena
Matsui Jurina

--------------------

Kimoto Kanon
Kizaki Yuria
Ogiso Shiori
Suga Nanako

--------------------

Hiramatsu Kaneko
Matsumura Kaori
Kinoshita Yukiko
Kuwabara Mizuki
Nakanishi Yuka
Furukawa Airi
Oya Masana
Mukaida Manatsu
Deguchi Aki
Hara Minami

Includes the future graduates because they haven't actually graduated just yet.

 

I just watched KII2 and it's awesome, and I loved it, and I learned all the KII girls again xD I'd forgotten them after KII1 OMG I SUCK. So I thought I'd do a ranking of KII members Although I kinda like them all.

1. Furukawa Airi
2. Ishida Anna
3. Takayanagi Akane
4. Sato Seira
5. Kato Tomoko
6. Uchiyama Mikoto
7. Ogiso Shiori
8. Saito Makiko
9. Sato Mieko
10. Wakabayashi Tomoka
11. Yamada Reika
12. Matsumoto Rina
13. Iguchi Shiori
14. Kito Momona
15. Akaeda Ririna
16. Mukaida Manatsu

 

oh ! i just found this thread
well then let's go straight to the ranks.

------ KAMI OSHI ------

--------------------------
Kizaki Yuria 木崎ゆりあ

------ OSHIMEN ------

------------------------
Matsui Rena
Yagami Kumi
Mukaida Manatsu
Isohara Kyoka
Kimoto Kanon

------ THEATER STAGE ------

---------------------------------
Team S 3rd Stage [Seifuku no Me]
Team S 1st Stage [Party ga Hajimaru Yo]
Team KII 2nd Stage [Te Wo Tsunaginagara]

------ SONGS ------

----------------------
Antenna
Choco No Dorei
Doubt!
Pareo Wa Emerald
SKE48
Party Ga Hajimaru Yo
Dear My Teacher
Seifuku no Me
Aishiteraburu
Gomen ne, Summer
Okami to Pride

 

Team S
Team KII
Team E
Kenkyuusei

——- KAMI-OSHI ——-
1 - Matsui Rena

——- OSHIMEN ——-
2 - Kitahara Rie
3 - Yagami Kumi
4 - Furukawa Airi
5 - Kizaki Yuria
6 - Kinoshita Yukiko

——- TOTALLY LOVING ——-
7 - Ogiso Shiori
8 - Oya Masana
9 - Kimoto Kanon
10 - Matsumura Kaori
11 - Nakanishi Yuka

——- LOVING ——-
12 - Hiramatsu Kanako
13 - Deguchi Aki
14 - Suda Akari
15 - Takada Shiori

——- LIKE A LOT ——-
16 - Suga Nanako
17 - Yamashita Yukari
18 - Kato Rumi
19 - Sato Seira
20 - Mukaida Manatsu
21 - Iguchi Shiori

——— LIKE ——-
22 - Kuwabara Mizuki
23 - Kito Momona
24 - Yakata Miki
25 - Abiru Riho
26 - Goto Risako

——- TOTALLY OKAY ——-
27 - Saito Makiko
28 - Ishida Anna
29 - Akaeda Ririna
30 - Kato Tomoko
31 - Sato Mieko
32 - Matsumoto Rina

——- FINE ——-
33 - Takayanagi Akane
34 - Matsui Jurina

——- MEH ———
35 - Hata Sawako

 

------ Kami Oshi: -------
1. Kizaki Yuria

------ Oshimen: --------
2. Takayanagi Akane
3. Matsui Rena
4. Yagami Kumi

------ Love: -------
5. Furuhata Nao
6. Kimoto Kanon
7. Ogiso Shiori

------ Like: -------
~ Mukaida Manatsu
~ Suga Nanako
~ Ishida Anna
~ Furukawa Airi
~ Kuwabara Mizuki

 

I find quite amusing how most of those who hold Jurina as Kami-oshi see Rena as one of their supported members while those who fully support Rena hold Jurina quite low in the ranking.

As for me, I've yet to know all the girls to be able to do a ranking. I hardly know some faces from SKE and I know almost no names besides the two Matsuis...

 

Umm, can i explain some sort of my mind here ?
You know, Jurina and Rena might be the biggest SKE member but they are exactly a different person.
Jurina is a perfect dancer with intelligent mind, energetic and joyful person - even AKB sees her as an ideal ace. While Rena is formerly a programmer who used to be in front of the computer (you can see her posture is not exactly .. perpendicular) is not too energetic, and ever feel stressed by the programs she used to build [not to showoff but i also feel this stress because i am a programmer too]. This divides those two into an exactly different person - a playful joyful one and a serious one.

Those differences maybe is the source of this phenomenon, those people who like Rena are mostly don't like Jurina (this is quite true because my programmer friends choose Rena instead of Jurina, too). But everything is back into the people heart, eh. Sometimes it's just a natural for someone to like someone else and to hate anybody else, just following their heart.

 

A lot of fans like both Jurina & Rena because of that reason, they are opposite but awesome in their own ways, is not like all Jurina fans dislike Rena or viceversa.... yes, there is some tension sometimes because of the "rival" relationship of them but a lot of fans are also fans of WMatsui.... so yes, there is people who love Jurina and Rena and that is not something strange or weird.... just saying

 

Okay, i was just responding Norenche's statement, this one :

And what i explained up there is merely just an opinion of mine.
Something like "Most of them" or "Some of the people" who like Rena might not like Jurina, that means not all of them, right ?

Some people here who posted their rankings are like that, if you see. Those who keep Rena in high rank are sometimes put Jurina in lower rank. But those who put Jurina in high rank are mostly put Rena in high rank too. That is the perspective of the fans themselves.

 

I'm agree with krisnandikaji they are two different person but back to the topic xD

Team S
Team KII
Team E
Kenkyuusei

——- KAMI-OSHI ——-
1 - Matsui Rena

——- OSHIMEN ——-
2 - Kitahara Rie
3 - Yagami Kumi
4 - Furukawa Airi
5 - Kinoshita Yukiko (↑1)
6 - Kizaki Yuria (↓1)

——- TOTALLY LOVING ——-
7 - Matsumura Kaori (↑3)
8 - Oya Masana
9 - Ogiso Shiori (↓2)
10 - Kimoto Kanon (↓1)
11 - Nakanishi Yuka

——- LOVING ——-
12 - Suga Nanako (↑4)
13 - Deguchi Aki
14 - Hiramatsu Kanako (↓2)
15 - Suda Akari (↓1)

——- LIKE A LOT ——-
16 - Takada Shiori (↓1)
17 - Yamashita Yukari
18 - Mukaida Manatsu (↑2)
19 - Sato Seira
20 - Kato Rumi (↓2)
21 - Iguchi Shiori

——— LIKE ——-
22 - Kuwabara Mizuki
23 - Kito Momona
24 - Yakata Miki
25 - Abiru Riho
26 - Ishida Anna (↑2)

——- TOTALLY OKAY ——-
27 - Goto Risako (↓1)
28 - Saito Makiko (↓1)
29 - Akaeda Ririna
30 - Takayanagi Akane (↑3)
31 - Ego Yuna
32 - Kitagawa Ryoha
33 - Azuma Rion

——- FINE ——-
34 - Kato Tomoko (↓4)
35 - Sato Mieko (↓4)
36 - Matsumoto Rina (↓4)
37 - Yamamoto Yuka
38 - Yano Azuki
39 - Fujimoto Mizuki

——- MEH ———
40 - Matsui Jurina (↓6)
41 - Hata Sawako (↓6)

 

Jurina probably "deserves" to be a lot higher on my list than she would be if I ever got around to actually making one, but it really is the fact I just like Rena's personality and Jurina's personality is just.. meh to me.

I have to admit if I had made a list 6 or 8 months ago, I probably would have put Jurina pretty close to last or maybe under an "overrated" header. And it's just why Norenche was probably trying to imply: resentment of her because of the perceived spotlight I feel she steals from Rena. Of course, Rena has won more Request Hours than Jurina ever has, but I dunno. I didn't say I'm rational about these things!

I definitely like Jurina now and realize that whatever she has, she definitely deserves. Even still, she probably wouldn't do much better than maybe top 15. THAT, is mostly because of a reason similar to what krisnandikaji says: I'm much more of a fan of Rena's personality type and not a huge fan of Jurina's personality. There's just something about Rena for me -- she seems almost incompetent when she's MCing, but in a lovable way. I laugh every time she does her "sexy pose" in RH2012 in the MC after Dareka no sei ni wa shinai. But the minute she actually starts performing she almost seems like a whole other person. The dichotomy between the two "personalities" of performing Rena and regular Rena stand out to me.

That's not to say I think Jurina has a bad personality; there's just nothing about her that jumps out at me. I guess I like my idols with some eccentricities, and I'm not even talking about Rena's history with COBOL, even if that means we have more in common than I thought we did (although I never programmed w/ COBOL specifically).

To stay somewhat on topic, I'll go ahead and try to list my top 20 at least. Excluding members who are getting ready to graduate (Ogi-chan, Hara Minami & Kuuchan would be on there otherwise at the very least).

1. Rena
2. Churi
3. Akarin
4. Yuria
5. Umechan
6. NanNan
7. Airin
8. Yukapi
9. Saito Makiko
10. MaiMai
11. Nao
12. Kyoka
13. Haruka
14. KoAmi
15. Saya-chan
16. Risako
17. Aya
18. Mieko
19. Non
20. Rika
21. Riho
22. Anna
23. Mizuho
24. Jurina
25. Manatsu

 

As a Rena-oshi you can always understand and knows how is your feeling to those WMatsui and the differences. Something i can't describe in words here [my feelings toward them].

Well it is also already time to re-rank my list

**THE BIG 16**

1 Kizaki Yuria 木崎ゆりあ
2 Nanako Suga
3 Matsui Rena
4 Kimoto Kanon
5 Isohara Kyoka
6 Mukaida Manatsu
7 Rie Kitahara
8 Niidoi Sayaka
9 Futamura Haruka
10 Takeuchi Mai
11 Furukawa Airi
12 Kato Rumi
13 Kinoshita Yukiko
14 Masana Oya
15 Takayanagi Akane
16 Saito Makiko
------------------------

 

update my list ~

My top 5

1. Matsui Jurina
2. Umemoto Madoka
3. Takeuchi Mai
4. All (except the ones above) Original Team E girls
5. Kinoshita Yukiko

 

Team S
Team KII
Team E
KKS

——- KAMI-OSHI ——-
1 - Matsui Rena

——- OSHIMEN ——-
2 - Furukawa Airi
3 - Kizaki Yuria
4 - Kinoshita Yukiko
5 - Matsumura Kaori
6 - Oya Masana

——- TOTALLY LOVING ——-
7 - Kimoto Kanon
8 - Nakanishi Yuka
9 - Suga Nanako
10 - Takayanagi Akane
11 - Mukaida Manatsu

——- LOVING ——-
12 - Suda Akari
13 - Deguchi Aki
14 - Sato Seira
15- Yamashita Yukari

——- LIKE A LOT ——-
16 - Kato Rumi
17 - Iguchi Shiori
18 - Ishida Anna

——— LIKE ——-
19 - Kito Momona
20 - Yakata Miki
21 - Abiru Riho
22 - Goto Risako
23 - Ego Yuna

——- TOTALLY OKAY ——-
24 - Saito Makiko
25 - Azuma Rion
26 - Kato Tomoko
27 - Sato Mieko

——- FINE ——-
28 - Matsui Jurina
29 - Matsumoto Rina
30 - Kitagawa Ryoha
31 - Akaeda Ririna
32 - Ichino Narumi

——- MEH ———
nobody

 

kami-oshi
01. Kinoshita Yukiko

oshis
02. Ishida Anna
03. Suga Nanako
04. Kimoto Kanon

love
05. Yakata Miki
06. Furuhata Nao
07. Matsui Rena
08. Shibata Aya
09. Kizaki Yuria

adore
10. Kobayashi Ami
11. Sato Seira
12. Mukaida Manatsu
13. Suda Akari
14. Sato Mieko
15. Takeuchi Mai
16. Takayanagi Akane
17. Matsui Jurina
18. Umemoto Modoka
19. Furakawa Airi

like a lot
20. Saito Makiko
21. Tsuzuki Rika
22. Futamura Haruka
23. Deguchi Aki
24. Kato Tomoko
25. Sakai Mei
26. Isohara Kyoka
27. Kato Rumi
28. Ego Yuna

like
29. Ichino Narumi
30. Matsumoto Rina
31. Yamashita Yukari
32. Oba Mina
33. Iguchi Shiori
34. Masana Oya

okay
35. Azuma Rion
36. Goto Risako
37. Kito Momona
38. Abiru Riho
39. Miyamae Ami
40. Nakanishi Yuka
41. Takagi Yumana
42. Mizuno Honoka
43. Uchiyama Mikoto
44. Yamada Reika

meh
45. Kaneko Shiori

 

SKE48 Member Ranking Top 40

Best oshi evah
01. Matsui Jurina

Faves
02. Futamura Haruka
03. Kizaki Yuria
04. Kimoto Kanon
05. Yakata Miki
06. Yamashita Yukari
07. Niidoi Sayaka
08. Goto Risako
09. Takeuchi Mai
10. Matsui Rena

Rabu
11. Mizuno Honoka
12. Tsuzuki Rika
13. Mukaida Manatsu
14. Suda Akari
15. Takayanagi Akane
16. Yamada Mizuho
17. Kobayashi Ami
18. Suga Nanako
19. Takagi Yumana
20. Nakanishi Yuka
21. Miyamae Ami
22. Kato Tomoko
23. Kinoshita Yukiko
24. Kaneko Shiori
25. Isohara Kyoka

Like
26. Iwanaga Tsugumi
27. Kitano Ruka
28. Umemoto Madoka
29. Oya Masana
30. Deguchi Aki
31. Saito Makiko
32. Ichino Narumi
33. Furukawa Airi
34. Matsumoto Rina
35. Azuma Rion

Okay
36. Furuhata Nao
37. Sato Mieko
38. Abiru Riho
39. Ego Yuna
40. Ishida Anna


Song Ranking (not including stage songs)

Spoiler

Best song evah
01. Darkness

Really great songs
02. Kataomoi Finally
03. Two Roses
04. Sunenagara, ame...
05. Aishiteraburu!
06. Choco no dorei
07. Hanikami Lollipop
08. Oki Doki
09. Bazooka hou hassha!
10. Halation
11. Hula Hoop de GO! GO! GO!
12. Aozora kataomoi
13. Tori wa aoi sora no hate wo shiranai
14. Mitsubachi Girl
15. Kamoku na tsuki
16. 1! 2! 3! 4! Yoroshiku!
17. Papa wa kirai
18. Tsuyogari tokei
19. Koe ga kasureru kurai
20. Pareo wa Emerald

 

Team S
Team KII
Team E
KKS

——- KAMI-OSHI ——-
1 - Matsui Rena

——- OSHIMEN ——-
2 - Furukawa Airi
3 - Matsumura Kaori (↑2)
4 - Kinoshita Yukiko
5 - Kizaki Yuria (↓2)
6 - Oya Masana

——- TOTALLY LOVING ——-
7 - Nakanishi Yuka (↑1)
8 - Suga Nanako (↑1)
9 - Kimoto Kanon (↓2)
10 - Takayanagi Akane
11 - Kato Rumi (↑5)

——- LOVING ——-
12 - Suda Akari
13 - Deguchi Aki
14 - Sato Seira
15- Mukaida Manatsu (↓4)

——- LIKE A LOT ——-
16 - Yamashita Yukari (↓1)
17 - Ishida Anna (↑1)
18 - Iguchi Shiori (↓1)

——— LIKE ——-
19 - Kito Momona
20 - Yakata Miki
21 - Abiru Riho
22 - Goto Risako
23 - Ego Yuna

——- TOTALLY OKAY ——-
24 - Saito Makiko
25 - Azuma Rion
26 - Kato Tomoko
27 - Sato Mieko

——- FINE ——-
28 - Kitagawa Ryoha (↑2)
29 - Matsumoto Rina
30 - Akaeda Ririna (↑1)
31 - Ichino Narumi (↑1)
32 - Matsui Jurina (↓4)

——- MEH ———
nobody

 

So after following SKE for a little while I started on a member ranking... Not much yet but I basically decided on my top 36 current xxx48 members and a few SKE girls are on there so better something than nothing right? XD (Why top 36? Because I got tired of typing after that. XD)

0. Hata Sawako (0 because graduated and first favorite and stuff but not current so yeah.)
1. Furukawa Airi
2. Matsui Jurina
3. Nakanishi Yuka
4. Takayanagi Akane
5. Azuma Rion (saw the 6th gen performance and I really like her voice, I will keep an eye out for her)
6. Matsumura Kaori
7. Matsui Rena
8. Suda Akari

...I don't really know the others well enough just yet ^^; And 6-8 aren't in my top 36 but they're the others who I have an opinion on so far... XD

Also, 3 and 4 are just one spot away from each other in my overall xxx48 girls rank. XD The rest are spread out though.

Well I kinda know 8 current members, it's better than nothing right? lol (Well I know a few more but have not formed an opinion just yet. lol)