Discussion in 'General AKB48 Discussion' started by ForrestFuller, Sep 7, 2014.
Voting Has Ended
Stage48 Countdown: Episode 89 (Best SKE48 Team E Members of all Time)
Welcome everybody to Episode 89 of Stage48 Countdown, I'm Forrest Fuller. On today's episode, we will be counting down the 10 Best SKE48 Team E Members of all Time. Before we began, let's look at the 5 girls who were just shy of making the countdown. Your Honorable Mentions, here they are.
11) Kyoka Isohara (50 Points)
12) Shiori Kaneko (34 Points)
13) Yukari Yamashita (33 Points)
14) Haruka Kumazaki (32 Points)
15) Nanako Suga (31 Points)
Now onward to the Countdown.
10) Rion Azuma (51 Points)
9) Rara Goto (57 Points)
8) Sato Sumire (63 Points)
7) Madoka Umemoto (66 Points)
6) Nao Furuhata (87 Points)
5) Kanon Kimoto (103 Points)
4) Marika Tani (129 Points)
3) Akari Suda (140 Points)
2) Aya Shibata (148 Points)
1) Rena Matsui (198 Points)
Rena Matsui takes the top spot. While Rena Matsui was only a Team E Member for 2 years (April 13, 2013 to August 31, 2015). She made a big impact with the team, She was the Leader (SKE48 Term for Captain) of Team E from April 2013 to February 2014 (taking over for our #7 girl Madoka Umemoto) and she kept the awesomeness going that Umemoto had did as Leader from 2010-2013. In February 2014, she was replaced by Akari Suda as Leader (to which she is to this day).
Shibata Aya is #2. You can somewhat say with her, that she is a Team E Lifer (even though she was a member of Team KII from April 13, 2013 to February 24, 2014) she was moved back to Team E and is still a member of Team E to this day and I'm guessing still will be a member until she graduates from SKE48. During her time in Team E, she became one of the breakout members for the 48Gs. Even though she was a Team KII member at the time, she ranked 17th in the 2013 SSK (which was at the time, the highest debut for a first time ranked member until 2014). During 2013, she became a full time senbatsu member (with Sansei Kawaii being her very first single she was a senbatsu member of).
Akari Suda takes the 3rd spot. While this was before her time as a Team E Member, she is the first member not named Jurina Matsui and Rena Matsui to make Senbatsu during AKB48's Senbatsu Elections. She became a Team E Member in February 2014 (and as mentioned before, she became Team E Leader to which she still is to this day). Pretty much she is keeping the Umemoto/Matsui Team E Legacy going. 1/3 of the Dasu, Tsuma, and Nita unit (or as a I like to call them, the 3 SKE48 stooges lol). She is somebody who is knowing for her charming and charismatic personality (especially during HS Events), I think you can say that's one of the reasons why her HS sales are pretty good.
Before we began with Episode 90, was going to have this weeks list be Best Sousenskyo Posters 2016, but giving the fact that we haven't seen the rest of them (only the AKB48 Posters that were leaked), the topic won't be voted on this week (next week might be the date since the SSK Guide Book is released this week) and we will get the rest of the girls Posters (SKE48, NMB48, HKT48, and NGT48 ones). Anyways, time for Episode 90 voting
Biggest Senbatsu Snubs
When you see or hear about the Senbatsu for a group's next single. Of course you know who the usual girls will be, but there are girls who got left out and you wonder, WHAT THE F*CK!, How could you leave this girl out? These are the 10 Biggest Senbatsu Snubs.
Of course you know these are Senbatsus snubs from AKB48, SKE48, NMB48, HKT48, JKT48, SNH48, Nogizaka46, and SDN48.
You can vote for your Kami-Oshi here (anywhere from 1st to 10th), Am limiting it to 1 member for a specific single (or coupling song) that you feel they should have been in. While I did mention single. This is for Singles, Coupling Songs (like an Undergirls (or an UG Song disgused as a different name)). Of course Senbatsu for AKB48 SSK Singles and AKB48 Janken Singles (2009-2013) aren't allow (but the Coupling Songs will be allowed, expect for the Team Songs of course).
Voting Begins Now
Voting Ends on May 23rd
1. Akimoto Sayaka (strong potential and was left out too early)
2. Sato Amina (she got 8th place and after that she got almost nothing)
3. Kitahara Rie (when her downfall happened)
4. Takajo Aki (same here)
5. Watanabe Miyuki (just in AKB singles)
6. Kinoshita Yukiko (amazing talent and still was left out of senbatsu plenty of times)
7. Miyamae Ami (got center and then out in a matter of seconds)
8. Matsumura Kaori (mgmt. really hates her, when even though she has recognition she's still out)
9. Owada Nana (used to be the 15th gen ace and now she's gone of senbatsu)
10. Tano Yuka (same here)
Watanabe Miyuki in AKB
1. Sato Amina ( ranked 3 times in senbatsu but never get to be a full time senbatsu member )
2. Akimoto Sayaka ( strong leadership potential )
3. Shibata Aya ( ranked 2 times in akb's senbatsu but hardly stand in the front of ske's songs )
4. Kashiwagi Yuki ( when she finally become center in a-side single, it's a double and with just 3 sec long appearance in the pv )
5. Itano Tomomi ( first time being a center and it's a four people center!)
6. Muto Tomu ( get pushed then ranked as senbatsu, but when younger girls come, she doesn't even taste the feelling of being a full time senbatsu member )
7. Matsumura Kaori
8. Tano Yuka
9. Watanabe Miyuki
10. Watanabe Mayu ( people and mgmt told her to be the next ace, but when older gen leave and younger gen come, mgmt just pushed her aside to be the younger gen's accessories that make people still attracted to watch the group )
1. Sato Amina
2. Yamada Mizuho
3. Kashiwagi Yuki
4. Matsumura Kaori
5. Kondo Rina
6. Tano Yuka
7. Murashige Anna
8. Kinoshita Yukiko
9. Futamura Haruka
10. Shibata Aya
Are the snubs limited to members that you think should be chosen but not or members that you think should be featured more prominently in the single? Matsumura Kaori would be the example for the first and Kashiwagi Yuki would be the example for the 2nd.
01. Sato Amina
02. Akimoto Sayaka
03. Nakamoto Himeka
04. Tomu Muto
05. Kuramochi Asuka
06. Kinoshita Momoka
07. Takahashi Juri
08. Kitano Hinako
09. Kusaka Konomi
10. Kameida Emika
Sent from my SM-A300FU using Tapatalk
members that you think should be chosen but not.
1. Akimoto Sayaka
2. Maria Desy (JKT48)
3. Sato Amina
4. Kinoshita Yukiko
5. Tano Yuka
6. Shibata Aya
7. Kuramochi Asuka
8. Masuda Yuka
9. Kitahara Rie (during her downfall pre-NGT)
10. Hirata Rina
1. Miyazawa Sae. Only applies for UZA.
I have no other point to make.
1. Sato Amina
2. Akimoto Sayaka
3. Kinoshita Momoka
4. Kitahara Rie
5. Muto Tomu
1. Watanabe Miyuki (AKB singles)
2. Matsumura Kaori
3. Murashige Anna
4. Miyamae Ami
5. Nishino Miki
6. Owada Nana
7. Akiyoshi Yuka
8. Ueki Nao
9. Muto Tomu
10. Kitahara Rie
1. Kitahara Rie
2. Miyazaki Miho
3. Sato Amina
4. Akimoto Sayaka
5. Muto Tomu
6. Nishino Miki (while also a Three Muskateer, Kojima and Naachan made senbatsu in both BwT and TwI and Miki didn't)
7. Takajo Aki
8. Matsumura Kaori
9. Shibata Aya
10. Muto Tomu
1. Watanabe Miyuki (AKB48 Singles)
2. Takajo Aki
3. Nakamoto Himeka
4. Kawakami Rena
5. Yogi Keira
6. Mukaida Manatsu (she was dropped at Oki Doki like WTF)
7. Yagura Fuuko (Before Jo's 1st graduation)
8. Sato Amina
9. Akashi Natsuko
10. Nakata Chisato
Mita Mao, Shimazaki Haruka (pre-2012), Nagao Mariya, Katayama Haruka, Ishida Haruka, Mita Mao, Nojima Kano, Yamagishi Natsumi, Kurokawa Hazuki, Suzuki Mariya, Sinka Juliani, Thalia Ivanka Elisabeth, Shania Gracia, Xie Ni, Tang AnQi, Wan LiNa, Yi JiaAi, He XiaoYu, Fei QinYuan, Yang YunYu,
Isn't this list for members who got dropped from senbatsu?? Desy has never been on JKT48's Senbatsu
1. Rona Anggreani -
Spoiler: #1 Reason
the duration from Flying Get to Kaze wa Fuiteiru...well, she has been nicknamed as the 'Little Yuko' of JKT for crying out LOUD! I can see that JOT is trying to promote some of the new girls but she's still at the top 5 Team KIII members imo...together with Yuppi, Kinal, Vienny, and Sisil...and she was the top 3 member before Kinal got transferred and before Sisil won the 2nd SSK...
2. Minegishi Minami -
Spoiler: #2 Reason
well, currently, I'm happy for her in being picked as one of the Senbatsu members recently..but it was during the time when Ikoma Rina was still an AKB Kennin Member...Mii-chan got kicked out of the Green Flash Senbatsu and she didn't made it into the Media Senbatsu of Kibouteki and BwT because of Ikotan...of course, the system is the one to be blamed..but STILL!
3. Sato Amina -
Spoiler: #3 Reason
Just like what the others have said...she was at the Senbatsu position at the 1st 3 SSK yet she didn't made it into a regular Senbatsu member
4. Suzuki Mariya -
Spoiler: #4 Reason
Being both AKB and SNH members is pretty hard, right? So, at least, both of the managements of those groups should at least put her one time on the Senbatsu of a single! She can memorize choreo quickly...she has a good voice...and a 7th gen member in which the AKB Management don't give a damn about...
5. Maeda Ami -
Spoiler: #5 Reason
The same reason with Mariyannu...she's a 7th gen member who got into Senbatsu for 3 times at the Janken, but it looks like the management seriously don't give a single damn with the 7th gen members...I mean, she's been in the group for almost 8 years and not a single Management Senbatsu for her...
6. Tanabe Miku -
Spoiler: #6 Reason
The only 3rd gen member that has only 1 freakin' Senbatsu position (Chance no Junban) and none for the Management Senbatsu...is her hard work for almost 10 years really not worth it?
7. Uchiyama Natsuki -
Spoiler: #7 Reason
When she was still a member, she's one of the slowly rising stars of AKB...and at least they could've put her on Kibouteki, JUST. THAT. ONE. TIME.
8. Li DouDou -
Spoiler: #8 Reason
She's like one of the faces of Team HII, yet, she didn't even made it into After Rain...and probably, she rejected the position at New Year's Bell, or the SNH management just thought of 'she's graduating so let's not put her in'.
9. Chen GuanHui -
Spoiler: #9 Reason
One of the superstars of Team SII...she full-streaked the Senbatsu from Heavy Rotation up to GIVE ME FIVE!, so, what's the problem why she ain't back in the management Senbatsus? A lot of singles could've been better if she was in..
10. Shinozaki Ayana -
Spoiler: #10 Reason
She's already a Senbatsu material for crying out loud! At least put her on a 32-nin or 36-nin Senbatsu already!
And that's exactly the reason why I picked Desy, JOT always makes her (and her fans) feel like she's getting pushed but nope, still not senbatsu, she was always in UG from Pareo to Beginner (Halloween Night does not count, since there's no UG unit for that single.
These are/were usually ignored despite their ranking and popularity among fans
And these are the ones (imo) that never been senbatsu (ignoring Janken) but should be considered:
I'll write a full list later, but the first member that comes to mind is Nakamoto Himeko for "Harujion ga Saku Koro"