rather than in the "Other 48", I think it's best to make a thread in the Idol Emporium since you said that Zest stated to treat it as a separate group
I wasn't following SKE48 so I try to find the source of this, and I found this post: http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?...-mini-kamifure-2021-06-16.23561/#post-1716319 However, the linked press release no longer contains the red text mentioned. So I am not sure about this.
As long as the members remain part of SKE48 then IMO it should be classed as a subunit even if the SKE48 name is never used by the group.
I guess that reasoning is kinda valid .... and I'm not going to mention the No3b situation .... No3b still has officially not disbanded ... but none of the members are current AKB members so technically maybe they should be moved to Idol Emporium? To make it clear .... I would oppose that move ... but it illustrates the sometimes complex relationships between sub units and the AKB group (the relationship of AKB, SKE, HKT is getting complicated enough as it is already as all sub groups are acting almost independently nowadays) You can't really even talk about an AKB group as it is right now imho
I'd say that for any related acts that begun its journey while its members are still active members of 48 group, their related threads should be in the other48 forum. For example, the "&" group that Nojima Kano became a part of after she announced her graduation, I think it'd be more fitting for that thread to be in the idol emporium subforum. While a group like Kamifure, it'd be more fitting to be in the other48 subforum.
Ok so, um, there's this thread in the BNK48 News & Releases area titled "LAST IDOL THAILAND" Question: what's that got to do with BNK? shouldn't that be moved to the Idol Emporium?
Similar to Last Idol, it is a show (and ultimately group) produced by Akimoto Yasushi. As Last Idol is in Idol Emporium, I agree. Moved.
Inoue Sayuri and Sasaki Kotoko are graduated from Nogi but their galleries weren't moved, please move them to the graduated section: http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-inoue-sayuri-gallery.4896/ http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-sasaki-kotoko-gallery.6088/ Also, can you please edit the title of Shinuchi Mai's gallery, somehow it's written "Shin'uchi Mai", please remove the apostrophe, thanks! http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-shinuchi-mai-gallery.6083/
Alice Margarita De Leon (Team MII), Aubrey Binuya (Team NIV), and Gabrielle Skribikin (Team L) have their profiles on the official MNL48 site removed since they have graduated, can someone please move their threads to the graduated members section? Thanks!
moved, had a bit of a brainfart so there is a temporary redirect for Alice De Leon, but that should disappear in a day
Nojima Kano's profile is no longer on the SKE48 website so can her thread please be moved to the Graduated section?
Please do this. and another thread that needs to be renamed is Abe Wakana's gallery, the title says "Abe Wakane" but it should be "Wakana", please edit: http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-abe-wakane-gallery.23345/
Shirai Kotono's thread is still in the Team KII section. She graduated months ago. Could you please move her to the graduated section. Thank you!
You know... http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/kamachi-yukina-yukkiina.23089 http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/matsumura-miku-mittsun.23100 EDIT: This one too. http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/miyazato-rira-ranrii.7721/
Souda Sarina graduated from SKE since 30th June, please move her thread and gallery to the SKE graduated section: http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/souda-sarina-sarii.7330/ http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-souda-sarina-gallery.7344/
Rikatii's thread now belongs to the graduated category. http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?...kati-5th-generation.15588/page-3#post-1728106 Maybe someone can move it please? EDIT: Ah nevermind, it's just been done. Thanks.
Please move these threads to the 'AKB Graduated Members' section, thanks! http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/onoue-mizuki-omizuki.23135/ http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/miyazato-rira-ranrii.7721/ http://stage48.net/forum/index.php?threads/the-miyazato-rira-gallery.7766/
Please move the following: Kyla Angelica Marie De Catalina (Team L) to the Trainees section Marsela Mari Guia (Team L), Nicelle Joy Bozon (Team L), Mariz Iyog (Team L), Anne Nicole Casitas (Team NIV), Aubrey Ysabelle Delos Reyes (Team NIV), Jhona Alyanah Padillo (Team NIV), Ruth Carla Dela Paz (Team NIV), Francinne Rifol (Team MII), Lorelaine Sañosa (Team MII) to the graduated section and I should ask what to do about the 6 promoted members of MNL48, they're not assigned to teams yet but they're considered as official members, should I add their threads to the Trainee section for the time being?