S48 Member of the Year 2011 - RESULTS!

I'm happy at this too!! Esp since I've read some rather unsavoury comments on other forums about her
I didn't actually negative vote anyone [sealed] because I don't think any girl deserves negative votes, it's either I vote for them or not

Would have thought Tomochin would have done worst with the amount of percieved hate there is for her! Surprising so many people hate girls like Rena, Yukirin, Yui and Sasshi!!

 

Stage48 votes only (54 participants)

 

^
btw, did you guys do a list of how many 1st place votes members received? It would be interesting to see the distribution of the "oshi" votes.

 

^
^ These results fit my expectations better and am therefore more pleased with.
^ lol, at what happened here just now. XD

 

^^
Here you are:

 

thanks Azarashi!!! I'll look through it.

thank you too Zobii -- saw your explanation (before you deleted).
I didn't read Naomi's explanation of the numbers at first but noticed that those 2 columns were there too.


edit: wow, kasai only has 1 oshi vote but is no. 8. Only 2 oshi votes for yuki out of the 48 people that included her in their list. rena only has 1 too compared to 4 for jurina. Ah and that 1 oshi vote for Fujikoso Yumi with no other votes whatsoever is good enough for 119th place.

 

I voted over there at Ebi48..

01. Matsui Jurina (+15)
02. Takayanagi Akane (+10)
03. Kimoto Kanon (+8)
04. Hirajima Natsumi (+7)
05. Takahashi Minami (+6)
06. Maeda Atsuko (+5)
07. Oshima Yuko (+5)
08. Shinoda Mariko (+5)
09. Yamamoto Sayaka (+4)
10. Ogasawara Mayu (+4)
11. Yamada Nana (+4)
12. Shimazaki Haruka (+3)
13. Iwata Karen (+3)
14. Takahashi Juri (+3)
15. Kojima Natsumi (+2)
16. Yagami Kumi (+2)
17. Kaneko Shiori (+2)
18. Umemoto Madoka (+1)
19. Ishida Anna (+1)
20. Furukawa Airi (+1)


--- Negative Points ---

01. Matsui Rena (-5)

Congrats to the top 21!


Once again, I didn't expect Rena to be have less total votes than Jurina since I there is a huge Rena following in both E48 and S48

I am guilty of down voting Rena though since I was expecting her near the top but the results were kind of surprising


The first 2 numbers in brackets are their previous rankings I reckon.

 

Firstly, thanks have to go to Naomi for organising this and for all the hard work you must have put in, it is much appreciated.

Fairly happy with the results, guess not surprised by the winner as she is someone who I think is likeable to everyone

Happy with Miichan's position

Surprised how many negative votes there are, guess i'm just too nice not being able to negative vote people. lol
Especially sad to see how many negative votes Miorin got

Here is how I voted:
01. Minegishi Minami (+15)
02. Nakagawa Haruka (+10)
03. Ichikawa Miori (+8)
04. Takeuchi Miyu (+7)
05. Nakamata Shiori (+6)
06. Maeda Ami (+5)
07. Matsui Rena (+5)
08. Sato Sumire (+5)
09. Oota Aika (+4)
10. Sashihara Rino (+4)
11. Shimada Haruka (+4)
12. Miyazaki Miho (+3)
13. Kashiwagi Yuki (+3)
14. Watanabe Mayu (+3)
15. Yamamoto Sayaka (+2)
16. Hirata Rina (+2)
17. Kato Rena (+2)
18. Urano Kazumi (+1)
19. Iwata Karen (+1)
20. Iwasa Misaki (+1)

 

I wonder who is the one who gave Takamina only single negative vote.

Total number of voters have increased only slightly. I guess explosive popularity growth in Japan this year did not transform into international fan scene.

Nice to see Kumi so high. I guess her role in MG2 helped a lot.

Edit: LOL I just saw my post count figure [666]. So I need to add something related - I gave my #2 place voting points for Jurina because of last year negative votes. A sort of protest vote against haters. lol

 

^
[hi]

haha, I initially gave negative votes to takamina, yuko and minegishi (the top 3 last year) but then deleted the yuko one cause I figured they would just offset each other. I should have checked last year's results so I could have voted where it counted more.

Oh and of course I like them, I was voting for the result.

 

Miichan is third! Same as the janken result!
Takamina really deserves her first ranking!!

Amina is the highest ranked member without any negative votes! [clap]

My Haruu!!
She ranks the highest in Team 4, with and without the negative votes!!
(Although Ranran has more people who vote for her )

I am glad that I am not the only one who voted negative for the member I don't like most.

EDIT:
I should give one point less to Nacchan so that she can get the #26 spot again!

 

I’m happy with the results, an amazing podium, indeed. [clap] And Miichan, third again!!! ( [hi5] to those who gave her positive votes) Some spots are quite surprising: Rena (25), Mariko (20), Sasshi (19), Kojiharu (17) or Yuuki (11). Myao (14) is surprising, too, but in a good way. Of course, Tomochin (11) is not surprising at all…

Ebi48 77. [ 12 | 11 ] Itano Tomomi (+61, -37) 24
Sta48 06. [ 21 | 04 ] Itano Tomomi (+164, -13) 151
Obviously, S48 is not the best place to… [sealed]

That's called 'The Matsui complex'...

My votes…
01. Minegishi Minami (+15)
02. Itano Tomomi (+10)
03. Sato Sumire (+8)
04. Oshima Yuko (+7)
05. Umeda Ayaka (+6)
06. Kikuchi Ayaka (+5)
07. Chikano Rina (+5)
08. Shinoda Mariko (+5)
09. Kasai Tomomi (+4)
10. Yokoyama Yui (+4)
11. Oota Aika (+4)
12. Kashiwagi Yuki (+3)
13. Maeda Ami (+3)
14. Miyazaki Miho (+3)
15. Takahashi Minami (+2)
16. Miyazawa Sae (+2)
17. Nito Moeno (+2)
18. Oku Manami (+1)
19. Takayanagi Akane (+1)
20. Yamauchi Suzuran (+1)
...and the negative ones...

Spoiler

01. Kuramochi Asuka (-5)
02. Yamamoto Sayaka (-4)
03. Watanabe Mayu (-3)
04. Akimoto Sayaka (-2)
05. Hirajima Natsumi (-1)

 

You know looking at these ranking i got a question, did the people who gave Jurina a high ranking give a negative to Rena? and those that gave a high ranking to Rena give a negative to Jurina? well besides from the few that just don't like the overly pushed Jurina and Rena.

 

^ I voted based on the oshimen tally thread and S48/E48 members' ranking thread

Expected Rena to get high votes (based on the number of Rena fans in the community) and then saw that Jurina is generally more disliked than Rena in the rankings as well

So voted for J and down voted R. Disaster struck when the totals was unexpectedly different from what I predicted.

The others I voted on are just the general fare: Nacchan cause I thought she needed a high vote to rank. Then the senbatsu staples cause I see the need for them to get high votes to counter down voting. Then NMB/KKS then back to SKE

I contemplated on down voting: Yui and Milky as well but I figured they'd end up with around the middle of the pack by their normal votes that it wouldn't be needed and here they go messing me up when Yui went top 10

edit:

Saw the 119 votes. Oh lol that's why. I'm pretty sure there's like 5 or 6 of us that gave our 15 points to the same person.

 

That's why i never vote stratigically, i simply vote down those that i dislike (Minegishi), annoyed of (Milky, Yui, Jo) or dissapointed of (Anna), likewise i voted only for members that i actually like a lot, although i'm starting to think that i'm an SKE MD rather than a Yuka oshi.

 

^ I'm not the only one who dislikes Miichan here

Didn't know there was such a rivalry between the two Matsui's, well at least their fans.

The funniest thing was the difference between points for Tomochin on Ebi and here hehe.

 

Yeah, I kept my votes simple - just voted for the girls who I thought were aight. And didn't bother down-voting anyone.

Also stuck with just 10 girls since it'd have been a hassle coming up a full list of 20 girls. (Not enough girls really grab my attention.)

 

Here is my list! I just voted positive since I don't hate any of the girls
I am REALLY happy for takamina win!
Overall I also like Yuko and minegishi getting there! congrats!
Its nice you also counts votes from other forum to get more people opinions.
The last 3 girls I select them from a lottery LOL I really wanted to vote for 20 girls.
Hope this is done the next year, it kind of gives the international fans a preview of who is the most popular outside japan

Spoiler

01. Takahashi Minami (+15)
02. Maeda Atsuko (+10)
03. Sayaka Akimoto (+8)
04. Itano Tomomi (+7)
05. Oshima Yuuko (+6)
06. Watanabe Mayu(+5)
07. Minegishi Minami (+5)
08. Miyazawa Sae (+5)
09. Kojima Haruna (+4)
10. Kasai Tomomi (+4)
11. Shinoda Mariko (+4)
12. Sato Amina (+3)
13. Kitahara Rie (+3)
14. Kashigawi Yuki (+3)
15. Sato Sumire (+2)
16. Matsui Jurina (+2)
17. Fujie Reina (+2)
18. Miyazaki Miho (+1)
19. Nachu(+1)
20. Abe Maria (+1)

 

Oh than a little warning, try not to tick the Minegishi fans of too much. Not all of them are good sports about it.

 

That's nothing to be surprised about, it's just that most of the biggest Tomochin haters left S48 and moved there. If you dislike her enough maybe you should consider joining the other forum, you will find a lot of people that share your taste there (just saying)